The 14 Best Cake Pop Makers in 2023

Things to Consider Before Buying the Best Cake Pop Makers

As you might have guessed, there are a few different factors you want to keep in mind when choosing the best cake pop maker. While all of the cake pop makers above have some excellent features to help you out in the kitchen, you may want to know more about what makes a decent cake pop maker different from one that is considered excellent. Below, we’ll delve into the features that matter the most so that you can decide which one is perfect for your kitchen.

Various Designs to Choose from When Selecting a Cake Pop Maker

One factor that is important to consider when looking at cake pop makers is what kind of design they have, especially when there are so many colors and styles out on the market. You’ll want to decide whether you want a neutral and understated appliance, or you prefer something with a pop of color that will stand out.

The next factor you’ll want to consider is whether the cake pop maker you’re looking at is non-stick. The best cake pop makers are going to have a non-stick coating that makes it easier to remove the cakes and more straightforward to clean up the appliance when the baking is done. You should also look for a hermetically sealed lid, which will help prevent the batter from getting onto the kitchen counter.

Another thing you’ll want to consider is whether you want a model that comes with a handle. This will make it easier to transport the device if you plan to use it anywhere other than your home.

Amount of Space and Size of the Appliance

When it comes to deciding on the size of your cake pop maker, you should consider how many people you plan to make cake pops for, what amount of space you have on your counter for the appliance, and whether you have somewhere large enough to store it when it’s not in use. Once you have those answers, you can determine what the best size option will be for you.

Next, you want to be sure that the cake pop maker you choose is capable of preparing enough cake pops for everyone you’re baking for. Some of the smaller models will make around nine cake pops, which is ideal for a small family. On the other hand, larger cake pop makers can make 24 or more small cakes, which works well for events and parties.

Cooking Features That Matter with Cake Pop Makers

The primary feature that you want to ensure your cake pop maker offers is the ability to cook all the pops evenly and thoroughly. While this can be tricky, our list of cake pop makers hit the mark, and you can read reviews for other models to get an idea of what you will be working with. Take a little time to research to be sure you’re getting a high-quality appliance.

Something else to look for is the presence of indicator lights. Having a way to look at the cake pop maker and determine whether it’s on and ready is essential. The power light lets you know the unit is plugged in and ready to go, while the ready light indicates that it has heated to the point where you can start your baking.

Lock Features and Their Importance with Cake Pop Makers

The best cake pop makers on the market will typically include a locking feature. Sometimes this can be done through a latch while other times a heavy lid is enough to do the trick. It might seem like this isn’t overly critical, but it’s the single factor that prevents your batter from overflowing and making a big mess on your counter.

Locking features can also offer other benefits that are useful during baking. It helps create even heating on the top and bottom of the cake pops. It also helps form perfectly round cakes when the dough is rising.

Other Safety Features to Watch for When Shopping

Assuming you have a high-quality cake pop maker, it’s going to produce a lot of heat while the cakes are baking. One of the safety features you should look for is insulation on the handle area, which helps to prevent you from burning your hands when you’re opening and closing the appliance. Some cake pop makers also have overheating protection, which will turn off the pop maker if the cooktop gets hotter than it should be.

Cake pop makers also sometimes come with a regulator switch with limits within a safe zone. There are also appliances that have a non-skid base, which keeps the item in one place so no damage can occur. By looking for these and other safety features, you can be sure your kitchen and family are safe from harm whenever you are baking.

Level of Versatility

There’s nothing wrong with choosing a cake pop maker that does its job well and doesn’t offer other baking and cooking options. However, there are also versions that can make things like cupcakes, sandwiches, donut holes, and even pizza. If you are interested in a model that is the most versatile, check whether the device you are looking at has additional cooking modes so you can use it for all sorts of different recipes.

Extra Accessories That Come with Cake Pop Makers

In many cases, the cake pop makers come with free accessories such as sticks, stands, recipes and more. All of these things will come in handy, so there’s no reason not to choose a unit that offers them without an additional cost. It can save you money and prevent you from needing to make extra purchases, allowing you to start using your pop maker as quickly as possible.

There are also several cake pop makers that include removable pans, which is another thing that can really make the baking process and the aftermath much more manageable. These are going to be much easier to clean and give you more versatility than devices without removable pans. If you’re someone who wants to make foods beyond cake pops, this is something you should certainly look for.

FAQ

Do I need to grease the cake pop maker or mold, even if it has a non-stick coating?

For best results, you might want to coat the cake pop maker or cake pop mold tray with butter, or oil. You can also use cooking spray. Greasing your non-stick cake pop maker or mold will allow for a quick release and it will help the cake pops maintain their shapes.

What else can I make in a cake pop maker?

You can make donuts, brownie bites, pancake balls, and many other sweet snacks in a cake pop maker. You can also make savory dishes such as garlic bread poppers, pizza bites, mozzarella bites, and lots more. 

How do I clean an electric cake pop maker?

If your electric cake pop is dishwasher-safe, you can simply put it in the dishwasher to save time and effort. If not, you will want to use warm water and a mild dish detergent to clean it. It is important to not soak the cord in water. You need to angle the cake pop mixer in such a way that the cord does not come in contact with any liquid. 

What can I use to decorate the cake pops with?

You can use melted candies or chocolate to coat the cake pops in. If you are using white chocolate, you might want to add in a little bit of food coloring to take it to the next level. Allow the cake pops to dry completely before adding in sprinkles, nuts, or fruits. You can also use a decorating pen or a piping bag to draw patterns on your cake pops.

The Bottom Line

Cake pops are tasty and super fun to make. You can decorate the cake pops to display them at parties or on special occasions as cake pops have the ability to make any party look better. It does not matter whether you are a professional baker or if you took up baking as a side hobby, a cake pop maker is an essential kitchen tool that allows you to enjoy your baking experience and explore your skills. Most cake pop makers are super easy to use but the best cake pop makers will allow you to make cake pops like a professional baker.