Best-Broiler-Pans

The 10 Best Broiler Pans in 2019

For shifting to healthy choices, broiler pan can be a good head start for you. A general broiler pan is designed for oven use and it makes sure that all the food vitamins, nutrients and minerals stay intact while cooking. The specialty about broiler pan is that it reflects heat from the top and makes sure that the item is cooked evenly at all parts. For cooking perfectionists as well, broiler pan is one of the favorite tools for cooking.

If you are looking for broiler pans to buy for your home, let us motivate you a little more by telling the advantages you will have with buying this product. Broiler pan will expedite your cooking time and you can cook meat with the least amount of oil possible. Hence, you can clearly understand that this item will save your time and also reflect positively on your health. 

For your ease, we have identified some of the best broiler pans for you. We will be providing you with a comprehensive guide about the best broiler pans along with how to choose the right one.

​Best Pick

​​Granite Ware Bake, Broil, and Grill Pan

There is simply no doubt that Granite Ware Bake, Broil, and Grill Pan, 3-Piece Set is our best pick from the lot. The name speaks for itself about the versatility of the product. It meets all our expectations of easy cleaning, utility centric construction and appropriate size for cooking and fitting into generic ovens. If budget is not a factor for you, simply opt for this product.

​Budget Pick

Nordic Ware Toaster Oven 2-Piece Broiler Set

If you are looking for value for money deals, we would recommend Nordic Ware Toaster Oven 2-Piece Broiler Set for you. This oven is suitable for both indoor and outdoor options and ideal for preparing small portioned meals and light snacks. We found the construction quite strong, durable and relevant to the needs.


1. ​Granite Ware Bake, Broil, and Grill Pan  

Highlighted Features

  • Great heat retention properties
  • Core material is carbon steel core, best suited for the purpose
  • Enamel outer layer for non-stickiness of the pan
  • Perforated tray for vegetables and fish
  • Right size and dimensions to fit in all types of oven
  • Purpose specific materials and pans

As the name suggests Granite Ware Bake, Broil, and Grill Pan is one of the versatile broiler pans for baking, broiling and grilling. It comes with a grill rack that you can use for barbeque or broiling meat. It comes with a catching pan in case the meat falls out. You can bake lasagna, roast chicken, meat or any other savory delicacies. It has a perforated tray that is suitable for cooking vegetables or fish even. Therefore, with this product in the house you can pretty much cook all types of savory items in a healthy way.

The core competency of this product is that it will make your meat’s color the right kind of brown after cooking. The materials are such that it makes sure that your meat is evenly cooked. The main material is carbon steel which is stainless and makes your pan strong and safe to use. The steel has porcelain infused in it so that it serves the purpose of non-stickiness while cooking. In terms of maintenance, you will have to be little careful about cleaning the products well after cooking.

Although they are dishwasher safe, we would recommend hand-washing them for greater longevity.  We feel it still is a pretty good deal since it’s already saving a lot of your cooking time. As far as the size of the pan is concerned, the roasting pan, broiler pan and the grill rack comes with an average area of 117 square inches each. This size is suitable for all general oven sizes and you can cook both tender and hard meat in them.

​Pros

  • check
    Versatile for cooking meat, vegetables and fish
  • check
    Ideal for evenly cooked meals
  • check
    Absence of all harmful chemicals
  • check
    Three-in-one product for baking, grilling and boiling
  • check
    Superior quality carbon steel core
  • check
    Strong and safe to use
  • check
    Broad cooking space

​Cons

  • check
    Less fall resistive

2. Nordic Ware Toaster Oven 2-Piece Broiler Set 

Highlighted Features

  • Ideal for outdoor recreational cooking
  • Non-stick feature
  • Suitable for toaster ovens
  • Ideal for camping stove and RV stoves
  • Better suited for light meals preparation
  • Convenient size and weight for portability

Nordic Ware Toaster Oven 2-Piece Broiler Set is mostly suitable for using in toaster ovens, RV stoves and camping stoves. So, if you love to cook some quality meat in your backyard, we couldn’t suggest you a better product than this. In fact, for camping or travelling this is one of the most suitable products for cooking. You can thank us later when you would be delighted with the use of product if you are regular traveler.

Coming to the materials of the product, its construction is light-weight and non-sticky. Non-stickiness is an essential requirement for proper cooking. The light weight however is provided to facilitate outdoor cooking and portability. Shrimp, fries, fish chips, sandwich, small pizza or whatever savory snacks you can think of, this item is suitable for making those.

The product is quite durable and maintaining it is not that hard. Given that the size is small making the cleaning process easier for you. However, the cleaning needs to be hand washed gently. The cooking surface is 8.5 by 6.5 inches giving you a considerable space to prepare light meals and dishes of small proportion. It is better for single use and preparing snacks and travel friendly items more.

​Pros

  • check
    Easy preparation of snacks
  • check
    Portable and travel friendly
  • check
    Outdoor cooking stove friendly
  • check
    Easy storage
  • check
    Maintenance is easy

​Cons

  • check
    Product is not dishwasher safe
  • check
    Unsuitable for cooking large volume of meat

3. Range Kleen Broiler Pans for Ovens

Highlighted Features

  • Non-stick surface
  • Durable and superior quality steel and overall material
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Cooking surface area of 8.5 by 13 inches

Range Kleen Broiler Pans for ovens comes with a broiler pan and broiler rack to provide the convenience you need while cooking. As far as the material of the pan is concerned, we were quite satisfied with its quality and usefulness. The core value of the material is the fact that they are made of heavy-duty porcelain-coated black steel provides the non-stickiness and toughness that you need for an ideal broiler pan.

The product is dishwasher safe which means that cleaning and maintenance of the product would not be a hassle for you. We absolutely loved the size of the broiler pan for home use. It is basically not to large or not too small. A perfect medium size broiler pan that fits in all types of oven and provides an appropriate cooking surface area for meat, fish and vegetables.

We were a little bit displeased with the versatility of the product, however. Why? We tried cooking veggies in the broiler but it doesn’t provide a satisfactory level of cooking for veggies. Cooking fish in the broiler is somewhat okay. But it is an absolute delight when one cooks meat in this broiler pan.

​Pros

  • check
    Convenient size
  • check
    Maintenance is easy
  • check
    Cleaning takes less time
  • check
    Made of heavy-duty porcelain-coated black steel

​Cons

  • check
    ​Coating goes off after heavy use
  • check
    ​Dissatisfactory performance while cooking vegetables

4. Range Kleen BP106X 2 PC Porcelain Broil and Bake Pan 

Highlighted Features

  • Pan and grill rack made of superior quality material
  • Materials are of OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) quality
  • Suitable for both outdoor and indoor cooking
  • Ideal for meat, fish and vegetables
  • Suitable for baking and grilling
  • Materials are dishwasher safe

A user-friendly broiler plan for broiling some good meat or baking is Range Kleen BP106X 2 PC Porcelain Broil. It comes with two pieces namely the pan and the grill rack. This product provides you the scope for some outdoor cooking as well. Yes, the design and material are such that the broiler pan is suitable for both indoor and outdoor cooking as per your choice.

The materials are similar to other broiler pans of the brand Range Kleen with heavy-duty porcelain steel. Whether it is meat, vegetables or fish, the product is suitable to cook all. There is a grill grate that takes away the extra fat from the meat. Talk about healthy cooking, right? Besides, you can use the broiler pan as baking dish to bake some of your favorite savory or sweet items.

Other than being versatile you can clean the product with ease and convenience as they are dishwasher safe. Although with broiler pans, we always recommend to hand wash them for longevity. The dimensions are 12.75 by 8.5 inches, a pretty moderate size for cooking medium sized meals.

​Pros

  • check
    Versatile, can bake and grill
  • check
    Design suited for healthy cooking
  • check
    Convenient size for portability
  • check
    Compatible with outdoor cooking
  • check
    ​Materials are durable

​Cons

  • check
    Unsuitable for cooking large sized meat
  • check
    The top portion needs to be cleaned with hands

5. Norpro 273 Stainless Steel Broil/Roast Pan Set 

Highlighted Features

  • Perforated top takes away extra fat
  • Small cooking surface area
  • Durable steel
  • Suitable for cooking chicken, fish, meat, bread and even shell-fish
  • Trendy design

When we talk about healthy cooking, this particular broiler pan comes to our mind at first. The materials are such that promotes healthy cooking at its peak. Norpro 273 Stainless Steel pan set is made of stainless steel along with perforated top so that the surface is non-sticky. It requires minimal amount of oil while cooking making it one of the healthy choices for broiler pans.

Due to the perforated top, the grease basically drains off. This means that a good amount of meat fat is taken away from the food. You can prepare items with chicken, fish, meat, bread and even shell-fish as the core ingredient with this broiler pan. The materials are dishwasher safe and quite durable actually.

The size is small of this product. You can cook enough meal for one or two servings. For large quantity meals, this might not be the right product for you.

​Pros

  • check
    Design is suited for healthy cooking
  • check
    Ideal for cooking variety of dishes
  • check
    Stable and strong construction

​Cons

  • check
    Unsuitable for cooking large quantity

6. Farberware Nonstick Bakeware 

Highlighted Features

  • Non-stick surface both inside and outside
  • Elevated flat rack with handles
  • Sturdy construction
  • Heavy carbon gauge as core material
  • Large size that fits into average sized ovens
  • Ideal for cooking meat, vegetables and fishes
  • Dishwasher safe

Among the products that we have reviewed to identify the best broiler pans for you, this particular one grabbed our attention for its unique design. Farberware Nonstick Bakeware comes with an elevated flat rack and chrome plated handles. This construction makes it an innovative approach to cooking healthy items on the menu. The elevated portion is there so that the excess fat can drip at the bottom of the pan.

The core material of the roaster is made of heavy gauge carbon steel giving the product the sturdy construction that it needs. Be it pork, chicken, beef or mutton you can cook anything in this broiler pan. The design is such that the heat reaches evenly around all places. This feature makes it suitable for cooking vegetables and fishes too. As far as the maintenance is concerned, washing the product might get a bit tricky due to its design.

Although they are dishwasher safe, we would advise you to wipe out with a clean cloth after washing it with dishwasher. The cooking surface area of the product is quite big. To be exact, the area of the broiler pan is 16 by 11.2 inches. This should fit any average sized oven. Also, you can cook both small and large quantity of dishes through this product.

​Pros

  • check
    Large cooking surface area
  • check
    Ideal for healthy cooking
  • check
    Versatile for preparing plenty of dishes
  • check
    Durable and strong
  • check
    Unique design
  • check
    Innovative construction

​Cons

  • check
    Cleaning is tricky at times

7. Granite Ware Roaster/Broiler Set

Highlighted Features

  • Strong carbon steel construction
  • Much safer compared to foil type pans
  • Non-stick surface
  • Drop resistive
  • Dishwasher safe

Granite Ware Roaster/Broiler Set comes with a roasting and broiler pan as the name suggests. This is basically almost similar as the broiler pan of Granite Ware that we reviewed before in the article minus the baking pan. This still made it to our list of best broiler pans due to having some distinctive features. To begin with, let us talk about the material and its design. The core part is made of carbon steel.

It has a porcelain surface meaning the upper layer is non-stick. If you have read up to this part of the article, you must have known that non-stickiness is a major requirement for broiler pans. We were particularly fond of its heat distribution mechanism. We do not know exactly how the manufacturers made it happen. You will see that the meat you cook through this pan is evenly cooked at all surfaces.

It provides a great texture to the meat. The product is dishwasher safe; hence you have less to worry about its maintenance characteristics. Like other broiler pans of the same brand, this product also facilitates even browning of the meat. The product has a cooking surface area of 19 by 12 inches. This huge cooking surface area means that you can cook large quantity of meals in no time.

​Pros

  • check
    Even heat distribution mechanism
  • check
    Innovative design so that meat browns better
  • check
    Durable and sturdy
  • check
    Easy cleaning
  • check
    Large cooking surface area
  • check
    Suitable for family use

​Cons

  • check
    Might not fit into small sized ovens

8. General Electric WB48X10056 Large Broiler Pan and Rack

Highlighted Features

  • Protective layer on the cooking surface
  • Easy ventilation mechanism
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Large cooking surface

No, we did not choose this product solely because of its brand value. When we evaluated the features of the product, we can assure you that the company completely lives up to its name and hype. When you are planning to purchase this product, make sure that you get your model name right.

With so many general electric broiler pans, it is quite common to get confused. The material is made such that you can easily heat up to a level of 500 Fahrenheit. This product works best with General Electric ovens actually. However, we see no harm in using it with other ovens as well.

The cleaning process is quite easy for this product. It is dishwasher safe and you do not have to wash it with hands at all. The size and structure is alright but it will not fit in ovens of all sizes. You would at least require medium sized oven to accommodate its dimensions.

​Pros

  • check
    Hassle free cleaning
  • check
    Suitable for preparing large meals
  • check
    Heat distribution quality is good

​Cons

  • check
    Sharp edges might cause inconvenience while handling

9. Nordic Ware Nonstick Broiler Pan Set 

  • Tri-ply construction with carbon core in between two aluminum layers
  • Quick heat absorption and retention
  • Effective heat management capacity
  • Slot rack for accumulating excess fat
  • Suitable for cooking meat, pork or chicken
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Provision for side handles

Nordic Ware Nonstick Broiler Pan Set comes with a two piece set for broiling meat, vegetables and chicken. To facilitate more diversity in your cooking options, it has a ribbed broiling rack and a versatile baking/drip pan. We were amazed with its tri-ply construction. To be specific about the details, it comes with a carbon steel core sandwiched with two layers of aluminum. Now why is this necessary?

This feature enables the product to quickly heat your dish, evenly heat up the item and efficient heat retention of the overall process. The two piece set makes it quite versatile in preparing your favorite dishes in a small time compared to other cooking stoves. You can bake, grill and broil with this product. Cleaning is not that time consuming as well. In fact, since the product is dishwasher safe, it only takes a couple of minutes to clean the product.

For transporting the product easily, it comes with side handles. We found that the side handles make the product pretty simple and convenient to use. It also has a slot rack that takes in the dripped fat from meat. Therefore, the design is made keeping healthy cooking and eating lifestyle in mind.

The dimensions of the product are 15 by 10 by 1 inches. This means that the cooking surface area is medium size. However the overall size is suitable to fit into all types of generic ovens.

​Pros

  • check
    Innovative construction for efficient heat management
  • check
    Side handles make it easy to use
  • check
    Portable and safe
  • check
    Design promoting healthy cooking
  • check
    Easy to clean
  • check
    Durable
  • check
    Moderate size

​Cons

  • check
    Not so suitable for cooking vegetables and fishes

​10. Frigidaire 5304442087 Range/Stove/Oven Broiler Pan 

  • Good looking design
  • Thick porcelain layer for heat management
  • Convenient size
  • Smooth cooking surface
  • Versatile in preparing plenty of dishes

A friendly brand name for all the kitchen tool lovers is Frigidaire. This particular model of broiler pan didn’t disappoint us at all in terms of utility and some great features. It has a layer of porcelain. Yes, you have guessed it right. This means that the surface is non-sticky and convenient for cooking some quality meat. That’s not only it. This provides a smooth cooking surface for you. In fact, this particular feature makes it quite suitable to clean the product appropriately. Hence, you have less to worry about its maintenance issues.

Frigidaire 5304442087 Range/Stove/Oven Broiler Pan has two pieces namely a top tray and scrapper. In terms of cooking items on the menu, it is suitable for preparing quite a good deal of dishes. You can cook meat, vegetables, chicken and fishes as well. The texture that is provides with the cooking is also on a satisfactory level. The product provides a cooking surface area of 14 by 11 inches. This means that it is suitable for preparing medium sized meat.

We were dissatisfied with the durability of the product. It is seen that after some months of use, the coating of the porcelain wears off and it might become inconvenient to use. The product might discolor after a year but that’s okay if it still provides a decent service.

​Pros

  • check
    Able to prepare diverse set of meals
  • check
    Smooth cleaning and cooking surface
  • check
    Protective coating for healthy cooking

​Cons

  • check
    Not so durable
  • check
    Discoloration might occur after a year

Things to Consider Before Purchasing a Broiler Pan

To make it easier for you to compare and make your final call on the purchase decision, we have structured our article in a way so that it covers all the relevant features of a broiler pan. Now moving on, to provide you with a better perspective, these are the things that need to be considered before purchasing the broiler pan.

The Construction

By construction, we mean the materials used in the product, the properties of the materials, the strength of the product and its overall design. The materials are important to check for two reasons. The first one is materials will show whether you can cook healthy and the heat management is efficient or not. The next reason is whether the materials used are safe for cooking. Another aspect is the non-stickiness of the surface. The material will give you an idea of that too. While browsing through the features of the product, check if the product has the following constructions:

  • Carbon or steel as the core material for efficient heat retention
  • check-circle
    • Porcelain surface for non-stickiness
  • check-circle
    • Aluminum for attractiveness and secondary layers 

The other part of the construction is the sturdiness and strength of the product. Also check the relevance of the construction for heat retention and absorption capacity.

Versatility

By versatility we mean the type of items that you can prepare using the broiler pans. There are some broiler pans that are suitable for preparing meat only. There are others which are suitable for snacks only while there are some in which you can cook pretty much everything. In this case, the capacity to cook a good number of dishes might not be the only deciding factor.

If you are particularly looking for a product that can cook meat only, you can limit your searches to those broiler pans only. Also, while evaluating if you find that the quality of the product is below average but it is highly versatile, we would recommend that you do not compromise with the quality at all.

Cleaning and Maintenance

If you are a homemaker or worker, cleaning is a hassle for everyone and we always tend to avoid it. For broiler pans, cleaning is not just an issue for convenience here. Since you are cooking a great number of meals in this pan, cleaning is important for safe food consumption as well.

Most of the broiler pans claim that they are dishwasher safe. In those cases, dishwashing can impact on the longevity of the broiler pans. The products might be dishwasher safe but it is always better to wash them with hands to get the best possible results. Therefore, you need to go through reviews of the product to understand whether the products are actually dishwasher safe or not.

Size

The size is important to know for two particular reasons. The first one is the fact that whether the broiler pans will fit into the oven that you are using. Hence, always check for the dimensions of the broiler pans. The next reason is the cooking surface area that it provides.

Small sized broiler pans are easy to transport but are unsuitable for cooking a large meal. So, from your end you need to decide which particular feature you need to prioritize. If you prepare large quantity of meals regularly, buying a small sized broiler pan might be inconvenient for you.

Conclusions

Broiler pans are great for health cooking with usage of minimum oil and providing a great texture to your meal with even heat distribution. When you are purchasing broiler pans, make sure you prioritize what you need first. Do not simply buy a product just because it says it’s of good quality. Browse through the features first and try to understand if those features are really relevant for your use or not.

If time is a constraint for your research, go for the product that has a medium size, ideal for cooking meat and poultry at least, sturdy construction and less tricky cleaning method. You can also skim through the pros and cons list to get an overall idea about the product and compare with the possible options that you have.

Pro tip- Warranty of a product usually reflects the durability of the product. If warranty schemes are good, this means that the makers are confident about the product quality and performance.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Pin It on Pinterest

Shares
Scroll to Top