A good roasting pan can prove to be a valuable investment. If you take cooking seriously or have a passion for cooking, then a roasting pan can be an essential piece of kitchenware that deserves a place in your kitchen collection.
Whether you are hosting large dinners for friends or family during the holiday season, you will require a roasting pan for smoking a chunk of meat for your summer barbecue party. If you absolutely have no idea about the investment choices that you need to be making, then you can go through this in-depth review.
You need to consider various factors before making a purchase. You need to check whether you intend to cook a large roast, ham or turkey. Also, the roaster should be sturdy and must distribute heat well. It should be versatile enough to be used frequently.
If you are looking to derive optimal performance from your roasting pan, then you should never ignore the factors to consider before buying the best roasting pan available in the market.
Table of Contents
- Quick Comparison: Top 10 Best Roasting Pans
- 1. Calphalon Contemporary Roasting Pan with Rack- 16 inch
- 2. Cuisinart MCP-117-16BR Rectangular Roaster
- 3. Circulon Miscellaneous Circulon Roaster with U-Rack
- 4. Calphlon Classic Hard-Anodized 16-Inch Roasting Pan with Nonstick Rack
- 5. All-Clad E752C264 Roaster with Nonstick Rack Cookware
- 6. Cuisinart CSR-1712R Roaster with Removable Rack
- 7. All-Clad E87599 Hard Anodized Roaster with Nonstick Rack/Cookware, Black
- 8. KitchenAid Kitchen Aid KC1T16RP Roaster with Rack
- 9. Tramontina 80203/005DS Gourmet Prima Roasting Pan
- 10. Viking Culinary 4013-5016 3-Ply Roasting Pan with Nonstick Rack
- Things to Consider Before Purchasing the Best Roasting Pan
Quick Comparison: Top 10 Best Roasting Pans
1. Calphalon Contemporary Roasting Pan with Rack- 16 inch
If you are looking to enhance your cooking experience, then you must opt for Calphalon Contemporary 16-inch Stainless Steel Roasting Pan with Rack. This new stainless steel roasting pan rack is extremely durable and provides superior conductivity.
Calphalon roasting pan is an excellent blend of premium performance and stunning design. It has been styled generously for accommodating a 25-pound turkey with much ease. The riveted handles ensure easy lifting. Oven-to-stovetop versatility is also offered to the users which can prove to be ideal for making gravies.
Excellent heat conductivity is assured by the sturdy stainless steel make in Calphalon roasting pan. The best thing about this roaster is that it is easy to clean and is broiler, oven and dishwasher safe. It is also backed by a full lifetime warranty.
The nonstick v-rack ensures even browning and cooking. It allows fat to drain away and ensures that you cook a healthier meal. The nonstick rack is coated so that the food does not stick to the pan. The side handles ensure easy handling. This roaster can be used on electric, gas, ceramic, induction and halogen stove tops.
2. Cuisinart MCP-117-16BR Rectangular Roaster
If you are planning to host a dinner party or a family get-together at your place, then Cuisinart MCP-117-16BR Roaster with Rack is all you need. The Cuisinart roasting pans are designed to hold turkeys, chickens, and large roasts.
The technology used in making these racks is ideal to distribute the heat evenly at the surface and sidewalls which helps in better cooking. It is easy to be placed in the oven. The food tastes better when cooked in these racks. The riveted handles make it easy to lift the roaster and move it around in the kitchen.
The tri-ply construction and the flat cooking surface ensure even heat conduction throughout. This roasting pan can be used for deglazing, hassle-free searing and gravy making on the stove. The pan is sturdy and big enough to accommodate a turkey of about 20 pounds. It can also be used to roast two whole chickens, a large roast and an entire one-pan meal..
3. Circulon Miscellaneous Circulon Roaster with U-Rack
If you are wishing to add unique and well-designed equipment to your kitchen, then Circulon Miscellaneous Circulon 17”X13” Roaster with U-Rack is the one for you. You can cook your favorite dishes from turkey to pork, beef, and chicken in this roasting man.
The product promises to give you moist and tender meat. The rack is oven safe up to 45 degrees Fahrenheit and helps you to prepare more delicious, healthier and tastier food. The nonstick is quality makes it easy to clean. Circulon roasting pan is one of the most unique roasting pans available in the market.
It has been designed with carbon steel and is significantly lighter when compared to other pans. The stainless steel rack offered along clips easily on the side and makes it nearly impossible for the 20-pound turkey contained within to slide around.
4. Calphlon Classic Hard-Anodized 16-Inch Roasting Pan with Nonstick Rack
The Calphalon Classic roasting pan does a great job when it comes to roasting chicken in the oven. The equipment provides enough space to cook Turkey, Ham, Chicken, and vegetables. This classic 16-inch anodized roaster features two double-riveted stainless steel handles that promise a secure grip while lifting.
The rack is oven safe up to 45 degrees Fahrenheit and is the best kitchen equipment to prepare delicious and moist food. The nonstick feature makes it quite easy to clean. So, next time you have friends coming over for dinner at your place, you know which roaster to go for.
5. All-Clad E752C264 Roaster with Nonstick Rack Cookware
You can now roast poultry, vegetables and meat to perfection with this multipurpose All-Clad Stainless Steel Roaster. Because of the elevated rack, the natural juices of the meat get collected at the base. You can use this juice for making gravies, basting and for glazing.
This cookware features a sleek polished exterior, is warp-resistant and is compatible with different kinds of stove tops. If you are planning for a holiday, you can carry this Cookware with you so that you don’t miss home food. It is an ideal choice for regular cooking as well.
6. Cuisinart CSR-1712R Roaster with Removable Rack
If you are looking for an ideal solution which can help you in both baking and roasting the food, then “Cuisinart CSR-1712R Roaster with Removable Rack”, is the one for you. It is perfect for everyday cooking. You will love to cook your parties and holiday meals in this roaster.
The sturdy construction and wide handles make it easier and safer to lift. This is a versatile must-have in your kitchen. It can help you bake some of the classic dishes of all time. Its construction allows quick and even heating for optimal performance. Since the base is also nonstick, it makes it easy to clean and to drain the extra fats and oils away.
This 17”x12” roaster comes with a removable rack and is just perfect for large roasts and turkey dinners. The fully nonstick design ensures that the cleanup is convenient. This roaster can fit into all standard-size ovens and is perfect for roasting and baking. Cooking surface and nonstick rack ensures lasting food release.
7. All-Clad E87599 Hard Anodized Roaster with Nonstick Rack/Cookware, Black
If you wish to experience an easy way to cook food then you need this versatile roaster in your kitchen. The nonstick coating makes it easier to clean. Next time, when you invite a large bunch of friends over, you know which kitchen cookware to use. This is an ideal roaster which is best suited for roasting large cuts of meat, poultry, and chicken.
The tall handles make it comfortable and safe to lift. The V-shaped rack allows the collection of the natural juices of the meat to get collected in the pan which can be further used to prepare gravy. It is a perfect choice in case you are looking for something that can cook large chunks of meat.
The tall straight edges of All-Clad E87599 Hard Anodized Roaster prevent spills and splattering. The signature handles offer convenience to the user while moving the roaster in and out of the oven. The v-shaped rack allows for even browning of the meat.
8. KitchenAid Kitchen Aid KC1T16RP Roaster with Rack
This versatile roaster is designed with three layer construction. Two layers out of the total three are polished with stainless steel and are surrounded with an aluminum core. The roaster has a capacity of 16X13X3 which can prepare your Turkey anytime.
This cookware will add to the aesthetic value of your kitchen. The beautiful polished finish makes it look unique and attractive. If you wish to indulge yourself in a rapid, even heat distribution, stable, and wonderful cooking, then you know your favorite roaster is here.
9. Tramontina 80203/005DS Gourmet Prima Roasting Pan
If you wish to cook a perfectly roasted meat, poultry, or fresh vegetables then you need to have Tramontina Gourmet Prima Cookware in your kitchen. You can even satisfy your baking skills through this cookware. The 18/10 stainless steel construction makes it a perfectly designed cookware for terrific results.
The sleek and efficient design of this versatile cookware makes it look beautiful when used in the kitchen. Next time if anybody asks you the secret of your fantastic cooking, then you know which kitchen appliance to appreciate.
10. Viking Culinary 4013-5016 3-Ply Roasting Pan with Nonstick Rack
Viking Culinary Stainless Steel Roasting pan is your next add-on in your kitchen. It is a perfect solution for home cooking. The roaster is an ideal choice to fit up to a 25 point bird. The elevated rack helps in even distribution of heat and provides overall cooking of the meat.
You can even use the surface of the vessel for reducing liquids and preparing sauces. You will be delighted to use this 3-Ply stainless steel clad. The handles are inverted so the vessel fits into the oven easily and takes lesser space than other vessels.
Things to Consider Before Purchasing the Best Roasting Pan
The first and foremost thing to consider is the size. You should go for a pan that has enough capacity to accommodate the largest items that you intend to roast without touching the sides. The pan needs to allow adequate air circulation for proper browning and roasting.
You need to remember that if the pan is too big, then a large portion of the bottom will be exposed and unoccupied. This can result in burning of the precious juices released while cooking. An easy solution for this is to put some chunky herbs and veggies at the home to prevent the juices from burning.
You need to remember that some pan size measurements also include the handles. So you need to double check the inside measurements to get an idea of what the pan can actually hold. A small roaster can hold turkey of up to 12 pounds whereas a medium size roaster can hold a turkey weighing 16 pounds. A large pan can work well for turkey weighing about 20 pounds.
The next thing you need to consider is the shape. Roasters are basically available in two shapes- rectangular and oval. Rectangular pans offer versatility to the users while cooking as these provide extra areas. Oval roasters possess sleek lines and work well with roasts such as ham, turkey and chicken. It is best to opt for rectangular pans with rounded corners as these offer best of the both.
You also cannot ignore the weight of the roaster. It should feel solid while handling but should not be heavy enough to make lifting cumbersome. Weight of the pan is essential to consider for a plethora of reasons. It should be able to take the heat of the oven and should not warp or twist while managing a heavy roast. Solid construction ensures uniform heat distribution.
The next factor to focus on is the material. Roasting pans are available in a variety of materials. These are usually made from cast iron, clad stainless steel and aluminum. Copper possesses the best properties when it comes to uniform heating and conductivity. This makes the transition from oven to stove easier. However, it is quite expensive.
Multi-ply or tri-ply cladding delivers exceptional performance in terms of uniform heating. It also prevents formation of hot spots and has the durability of stainless steel. The drawback of this material is that it is a bit expensive. You can also consider other materials such as cast iron and anodized roasters as per your convenience.
Another important feature to give important consideration is the handles of the roaster. This is because you would be lifting your pan along with the weight of the roast in and out of the oven. These obviously have to be sturdy enough to take the weight. Bale handles are convenient when it comes to storage. However, these can be unstable while handling heavy load. You should look for large loop handles as these offer the greatest stability to your roaster.
You need to always look for roasting pans that come with additional accessories such as racks. A rack raises your roast off the pan bottom and also ensures free circulation of air which is necessary for proper roasting. Racks also allow the natural juices to drop to the bottom so that you can make delicious sauces and gravies with them.