When you are a serious baker, you are quite literally playing with fire, and a seasoned baker knows better than to go near an oven without the proper safety gears. Human skin can suffer severe burns in only fractions of a second if the temperature is higher than 160 degrees F, while even the ovens used at our homes can reach up to temperatures higher than 500 degrees F. And hence, a proper oven glove or a mitt is an absolute necessity to ensure the safety of your hands and to provide comfort while taking your baked goods into or out of the oven.
If you think of buying an oven mitt, it might seem like it is as simple as it sounds, many people might say, “What is there to think, it’s simply a pair of gloves, right?” But once you start using an oven mitt, you will realize how many hidden aspects there are which can turn a pair of mitts to be the motivation to use your oven more or to turn your baking experience sourer than a badly-made lemon pie.
Moreover, there are tons of different variations of oven mitts on the market, and each of them differs in design, raw materials, size, user-friendliness, and many other factors. To make it easier for you to choose the right kind of oven mitts, we have put together the ten best oven mitts that you can find on the market today, and have compared them against one another, followed by their details, including their key strengths and weaknesses.
Easy to clean and versatile, this pair of silicone oven mitts have won the best pick position on our list. The fact that it is made of silicone and not fabric gives it a higher heat resistance and protects your hands not only from heat but also from steam and hot liquid.
Most of us would not want to spend a fortune on handwear unless they are from a designer brand or made of cashmere or leather. Keeping that in mind, we introduce you to our budget pick oven mitts, which are from HOMWE and gives your hand an excellent protection while staying in a budget range. They have the added advantage of being longer than the other ones, meaning they will help you to reach into the deepest parts of the oven without burning your hands.
Table of Contents
- Quick Comparison: Top 10 Best Oven Mitts
- 1. The Triumphant Chef Silicone Oven Mitts
- 2. Homwe Extra Long Professional Silicone Oven Mitt
- 3. Ove Glove, Heat Resistant, Hot Surface Handler Oven Mitt
- 4. Frux Home and Yard Black Silicone Oven Hot Mitts
- 5. RedLantana Silicone Oven Mitts
- 6. The Kitchen Haven Best Flex Silicone Oven Mitt Set For Women
- 7. OXO Good Grips Silicone Oven Mitt with Magnet
- 8. Mastrad Orka Plus Oven Mitt
- 9. Homwe Silicone Oven Mitts and Potholders
- 10. San Jamar KT0215
- Things to Know Before Buying the Best Oven Mitts
Quick Comparison: Top 10 Best Oven Mitts
After our best and budget picks comes the comparison between ten oven mitts on the market that can guard your hands while baking and cooking, and through comparing these products you can have a valuable insight into why one oven mitt might be the best one for you but the other one might not.
1. The Triumphant Chef Silicone Oven Mitts
Although in the past most baking gloves were made of cloth, these days the forerunner on the market of oven mitts are made of something else, and that is silicone. Silicone has three major advantages compared to the cloth.
First, they provide you with reliable protection against hot vapor and liquids. Since silicone repels liquid, they do not become wet or are affected by steam and will protect your hands from dangerous steam scalds and liquid burns. Second, they are very easy to clean compared to the cloth ones and they dry faster after washing.
Third, they are flexible and helps you to use your hands however way you want, to hold the baking pans, trays, utensils, etc. This is why this oven mitt from The Triumphant Chef, triumphs over the other ones with its silicone build and an exceptionally clever design. The outer surface of this oven mitt is made of silicone that has been approved by the FDA to be safe to come into contact with food.
What it means is that the mitt can not only be used to hold the bakeware but also the food itself, for example, a roasted turkey. A roasted poultry, right out of the oven can have a temperature almost as high as 140 degrees F and touching this food with a non-food grade silicone can be dangerous since the heat can cause material from the gloves to leach into your food. But with this safe silicon mitt, you can touch the turkey, hold it, cut it and handle it any way you want, without causing any adverse effect to your health.
Also, this would not be possible using mitts made of cloth, since they would become stained by the juice of the food. But since the silicone mitts are waterproof and oil proof you can easily handle any food material without worrying about your gloves becoming permanently stained. The interior of the mitt has been padded with a pure cotton fabric, which gives your hand a comfortable cushioning and also provides extra protection from heat.
The outer surfaces of the glove have been patterned with small "Y"s, and "O"s, which gives the surface a texture that makes it easy to hold onto pots and pans firmly without slipping. This texture also helps you to avoid having the stiffness that can result from the fact that all fingers except the thumb are in one compartment of the mitt. Due to this texture, it is also very easy to clean the mitt. If you need to clean the gloves in the middle of baking, you would not even have to take them off! You can simply go to the sink, put some soap on the surface with the mitt on, and rub the mitt against each other and they will be clean and also dry quickly as the silicon is waterproof.
Once you are done using the mitts, you can hang them at a designated area using the loop that is at the bottom of the mitt. The mitt also rewards you with a bonus pastry brush with silicone bristles which would come handy for adding butter, glazing, oil, etc. on your dishes and pastries
2. Homwe Extra Long Professional Silicone Oven Mitt
Anyone who has been baking or cooking for a long time would know that the forearms need as much protection as the front parts of the hand such as the wrist, palm, and the fingers.
For example, water might spill out to your entire hand including the forearms while trying to drain some pasta, or you might require to reach deep into your oven to turn your pizza or to make additions to a pastry that you are baking.
To help you in these kinds of circumstances, HOMWE has come up with a brilliant idea of making oven mitts that covers your hand including the forearms. This 14.7 inches long mitt that covers almost up to your elbows will allow you to confidently cook and bake at high temperatures without having to worry about burning the parts of your hands beyond the wrist. This mitt has been made of silicone that is safe to be used with food materials, is free of BPA and resistant to temperatures as high as 450 degrees F.
Since it is made of silicone it can protect your hands from liquid or gaseous heat, and not only just hot metallic parts or food. The texture of the silicon on the outer surface of the mitt prevents slipping and gives you a firm grip on anything you hold while wearing the mitts.
Moreover, the inside of the mitt has been covered with cotton and has been quilted to give you comfort and a soft touch on the covered part of your skin. Since the open end of the mitt is not too tight, air can easily flow into and out of the mitt, preventing your hands from becoming sweaty while you are wearing the mitt. Once you are done using the mitts, they can be washed either in the washing machine or in the dishwasher, saving you from the trouble of washing them by hand.
3. Ove Glove, Heat Resistant, Hot Surface Handler Oven Mitt
Although oven mitts are quintessential for protecting your hands from heat, they also limit your dexterity and control over the movement of your fingers and hand muscles to variable extents.
This can be a serious issue if your baking process involves tiny details since it will not be possible to perform when your fingers are not free to move or bend. As an answer to this problem, Ove' Glove has made a heat-resistant glove that keeps your fingers free to move, while being completely protected.
This does not look like a traditional oven mitt and has been designed more like a gardening glove. But do not allow the appearance to trick you into thinking that its heat resistance is inferior to the others. In fact, it can provide stronger protection for your hands since it is not only resistant to high temperatures, but also is resistant to flames. So if you like grilling, barbecuing, and other cooking techniques that involve getting your hands near hot flames, then it is a mitt that will give you excellent protection.
You might be thinking how this mitt was able to achieve such an impressive resistance to heat and flames, even though it is made of fabric. The secret to this mystery lies in two materials called Nomex and Kevlar that were used on the outer layer of the fabric. These two materials are used in apparels worn by firefighters, car racers, and military personnel due to their superior heat resistance and flame inhibiting abilities.
This means that the glove will not melt, catch fire or conduct heat for an extended period of time, making it a very reliable oven mitt. The outer layer of this mitt also has lines of silicone to give you a non-slip grip and the inside of the mitt has been made of cotton that has been knit doubly to give it a good durability.
4. Frux Home and Yard Black Silicone Oven Hot Mitts
Similar to the silicone mitts from Homwe that we have discussed before, these mitts from Frux Home and Yard Black comes in an extra-long design, which will keep your forearm covered and well-protected during cooking or baking.
Although the two products are very similar we would like to mention some differences between them. This mitt has geometrical patterns instead of "O"s, and "Y"s, so if you are looking for a more mature and elegant design, then you could go for this one.
Also, the fabric part near your elbows is shorter for this mitt, which means the silicone part is longer, which protects a larger surface area of your forearm from heat and hot liquid. This mitt also can withstand a higher temperature than the previous one, since it can endure up to 485 degrees F, whereas the previous one was heat resistant only up to 450 degrees F.So if you are looking for an oven mitt similar to Homwe, but with a longer forearm protection, higher temperature resistance, and more elegant design, then this would be a great choice for you.
5. RedLantana Silicone Oven Mitts
RedLanatana is a company that specializes in making silicone-based kitchenware and this mitt from them is a great pair of oven mitts if you are looking for a large-sized mitt. This mitt is 15 inches long and covers your forearm almost up to your elbows.
If you have a large oven and want to be able to comfortably and confidently move your hand around inside the oven, then this is a pair of mitts that you could go for.
The silicone that has been used to make the mitt is safe to be used in temperatures as high as 425 degrees F, and is resistant to stain and odor. The inner layer of the mitt has been covered in cotton to make your hands comfortable at all times. Due to the non-sticky property of the silicone, it is very easy to wash away any dirt from the surface of the mitt.
6. The Kitchen Haven Best Flex Silicone Oven Mitt Set For Women
Functionality, comfort, and a lovely feminine design come together in this pair of oven mitt from The Kitchen Haven. If you are looking for a perfect gift for your wife, mother or any female baker that you care about, this is it!
Instead of an opaque material, this mitt uses a heat-resistant silicone covering that is transparent and makes the underlying pink and white polka dots visible, making the mitt an aesthetically pleasing handwear. Not only is the silicone layer see-through, but it is highly flexible, to allow you the maximum amount of control over your hands.
The fact that it is flexible, and the soft, quilted inner layer gives you comfort while using the mitt. The outer silicone layer has patterns on it so that you can firmly grip onto hot objects without slipping or dropping the object. We also love the fact that this mitt comes with a free silicone spatula that you can use perform tasks such as mixing your cake batter or adding layers of cream onto your pie.
7. OXO Good Grips Silicone Oven Mitt with Magnet
OXO always comes up with unique and innovative kitchenware and you can see the company's dedication to staying at the top in their oven mitt as well.
This oven mitt has been made of flexible silicone on the outside, which gives you resistant to high temperatures of up to 600 degrees F, which is quite higher than the others on the list, resistance to flames, hot liquid and steam, while also being flexible enough to prevent it from restricting the movement and dexterity of your hands.
The inside of the mitt is made of a special fabric which is soft, comfortable to touch, stays cool and provides enough aeration to prevent your hand from becoming sweaty and sticky inside the mitt. The mitt also has raised linings of silicone to prevent the mitt from slipping, and to give you a firm grip on any large or small objects while you make your favorite dishes.Another feature of the mitt that we find to be unique in this product is the magnet inside the hem of the mitt, which allows it to be attached to any magnetic surface in your kitchen, for example, a steel bar, or your refrigerator, making it easy to store the mitt within your reach.
8. Mastrad Orka Plus Oven Mitt
The most common use of an oven mitt is to hold a hot baking tray or a pan to take it out of the oven, or to hold the hot handles of a cast iron pan, and if the mitt does not allow you to bend your fingers to comfortably hold something, the mitt does not have much use.
But it can be quite tricky using silicone oven mitts since they do not fit on your hand like the fabric ones do, and also they have the thumb compartment on the side, so you have to bend your thumb forward to grab or hold onto something.
The company Mastrad recognized this design flaw and gave their mitt a new twist in the designing. They brought the thumb part of the mitt to below the part where your four other fingers are so that your hand is naturally ready to hold onto anything while wearing the mitt. This clever designing of this mitt makes it far more user-friendly than the other silicone oven mitts. This special shape, and the outer silicone covering of the mitt, which is resistant to temperatures as high as 480 degrees F, allow you to even pick something up, like a potato, from boiling water.
It also has another great feature that is not present in the other mitts, which is that you can take apart the inner cotton lining for cleaning purposes. The cotton mitt securely stays attached to the silicone covering by a button and provides you additional insulation from heat and keeps your hand comfortable but if you want to remove it, you can easily do so by opening the button and taking it out of the silicone mitt.
Another great thing that we love about this mitt is that it comes as a single mitt rather than a pair, which is very useful if you lose only one side of the pair and want a replacement. You can simply order another one and would not have to spend money on a new pair of mitts.
Not only is this mitt very user-friendly, but also has a smooth luster on its surface which gives it an aesthetic appearance. Once you are done using the mitt, you can wash it and hang it anywhere you want to, through the loop that is at the lower end of the mitt.
9. Homwe Silicone Oven Mitts and Potholders
When buying protective gear for baking and cooking, many of us face the confusion of whether to go for a potholder or a pair of an oven mitt. If you are having a hard time choosing which one to go for, this set could be your answer.
This set by Homwe includes a pair of silicone oven mitts and a pair of silicone potholders! Moreover, the pot holders that are in this set are 7-inch squares and can be also used as trivets on which you can place hot pans and plates to protect your table surface.
The silicone oven mitts come in a classic black color and anti-slip raised patterns on the outer surface. If you have been disappointed by mitts that are either too long or too short, you would love the optimum length of this mitt. It has just the right size to give your wrist and a portion of your forearm a well-covered protection from heat, but not too long to disturb your hand movements.Just like the oven mitt, the pot holders in this set come with a textured surface which prevents it from becoming slippery even when it is wet. Due to this texture, the pot holders can also be used in versatile ways such as for opening a tight lid on a jar, or as coasters. The potholders and the mitts are made of silicone that can withstand temperatures as high as 450 degrees F and are suitable for heat protection, both inside and outside the kitchen. The potholders have a hole at its corner so that you can hang it in any convenient place and prevent them from being lost.
10. San Jamar KT0215
This simple yet powerful oven mitts from San Jamar employs two latest technologies in the field of heat protective materials. The maroon colored upper parts of the mitt have been made of Nomex fabric, which gives the mitt a high resistance to heat and flame,while the yellow fabric on the underside, made of Kevlar fabric gives it resistance to abrasive damage, cuts, and high temperatures.
These two superior heat-resistant materials used in the fabric of the mitt and also its design has earned it a certification from NSF to be safe to be used in commercial food service settings.
It has also been graded as a Class II oven mitt by the same agency. What it means is that it is effectively resistant to flame and high temperatures both in dry and wet conditions. As a result, it can withstand temperatures as high as 535 degrees F for 30 seconds, does not melt when exposed to flames, and meets other high-standard requirements of heat protection according to NSF.The mitt is 15 inches long to provide your forearms an effective barrier against steam, high temperatures, and steam, but to ensure that the length does not compromise your hand’s movement, the cuff of the mitt has been shaped at an angle. When you want to clean the mitts, you can easily wash it in any laundry machine and dry it using either its magnet or hanging loop.
Things to Know Before Buying the Best Oven Mitts
You have looked at our selected oven mitts and have finished comparing them. Now what? Although we are not asking you to be experts on oven mitts, we think that there are some important things to know about oven mitts, which will help you to decide which oven mitt will help you the most in your everyday cooking and baking.
What Kind of Materials are Used to Make an Oven Mitt?
Most of us can relate to the memories of our grandmothers using quilted fabric oven mitts to bake us our favorite treats and although cotton or other fabric mitts can bring back sweet memories, they have some major disadvantages in practical settings. Hence, most oven mitts of our times are made of heat resistant and flexible silicone on the outside, with a comfortable fabric lining on the inside.
Although silicone oven mitts have one common complaint from many users, which is that they are bulky and restrict the hands’ movement and dexterity, many users have also said that they do become used to wearing silicone mitts and once they are accustomed, silicone mitts work great. Moreover, silicone mitts have many other advantages over cotton mitts, for example, they can be washed and dried very easily, are waterproof and will protect your hands from steam and hot liquids, and hence they are not stitched like the cotton ones, there is no fear of holes or tears forming on your mitts.
Although silicone oven mitts look like they are here to stay, if you want the latest technology for heat protection, which is far more superior to the other materials including silicone, then you should be looking at mitts made of Nomex and Kevlar. Nomex and Kevlar are two materials that belong to the same chemical family called aramid polymers. These materials are used in apparels worn by firefighters, military personnel, and race car drivers. These other applications of Nomex and Kevlar show that they are reliable for heavy duty purposes and are at the top when it comes to effectively guarding you against heat, flame, and steam.
The big plus point of these two materials is that unlike silicone, which has a texture closer to plastic and rubber, Nomex and Kevlar can be woven into a fabric. And fabric mitts are more flexible, comfortable and easy to wear than the silicone ones. So if you have been looking for an oven mitt with the comfortable feels of fabric mitt but high heat resistance that silicone can provide, then spend a little more and going for Nomex and Kevlar mitts might be worth the investment for you.
Oven mitts are something that you wear on your hands and so the size is a more important aspect for them compared to other kitchen tools. Just as you would consider your waist size when buying a pair of jeans, it is important to know the length of your hand, your wrist girth, etc. and compare it with the size of the mitt to see whether the mitt will be small or oversized for you.
Although size of your hands and the size of the mitt should be carefully assessed, it is also important to note that most oven mitts, especially the silicone ones are not made to fit your hands perfectly and as long as the mitt does not fall off from your hand or is not flexible enough to be bend to allow free hand movement, the mitt will work fine even if it is not the perfect fit. Another thing to consider is the length of the mitt. Some mitts are long enough just to cover your wrist, but if you have a large oven and want to reach deep into it with your hand, it is wise to go for the extra-long mitts which will give full protection to your forearms along with your wrist.
The major part of the design of a mitt that determines its functionality is the patters on the outer surface. If you have ever had a silicone mat or a pot holder become slippery by water or oil, you would know how difficult it is to hold something with it. And hence, it is essential for any oven mitt to have a texture or raised patterns which will prevent your hand from slipping and offer you a firm grip on anything that you are trying to hold.
Another thing to consider about the design is how comfortable it makes your mitt to wear. As a part of the design, most silicone mitts have an inner cotton lining. This is very important as this inner layer gives you extra insulation, keeps your hand cushioned and comfortable, and also prevents your hand from becoming sweaty while wearing the mitt.
Last but not the least, the most obvious part of the design is the appearance. If an oven mitt is fully functional but does not look nice enough to make you feel like wearing it, then what's the point? Although there are no frills or laces involved when looking for this type of handwear, the good news is that you still have a lot of options when it comes to the color. Many silicone oven mitts give you the option to choose from multiple attractive colors and there are ones that even have adorable polka dots pattern.