Best Ice Cream Containers

The 6 Best Ice Cream Containers in 2023

"Disclaimer: Thank you for reading our post and in full transparency, we may earn an affiliate commission when you buy products through our links. This will not cost you anything extra, but the small commission we receive helps keep funding our reviews and articles. Learn more about our review process here."

What is the better than buying your favorite ice cream at the grocery store? Making your own ice cream, of course. But, where should you put all that ice cream once you’re done making it? Enter, the ice cream container.

While you could put your newly-made ice cream in just about any container, having one of the best ice cream containers can go a long way to better preserving your ice cream while also preserving space in your freezer.

Best Pick

SUMO Homemade Ice Cream Containers

The SUMO Homemade Ice Cream Containers is the best of the best and comes in a pack of two containers. It’s sleek and slim size allows it to be economically filled with ice cream while being very efficient in storing it in your freezer. An all-around excellent ice cream container and one that gives you the best value.

Budget Pick

StarPack Home Ice Cream Freezer Storage Containers

Budget shoppers will be delighted with the StarPack Home Ice Cream Freezer Storage Containers. This pack comes with two ice cream containers and besides its great affordability, it also does a fantastic job at being great vessels for your ice cream. There’s plenty of space inside for your ice cream and can also be used for other foods as well.


Quick Comparison: Top 6 Best Ice Cream Containers



The SUMO Homemade Ice Cream Containers are the best ice cream containers for many different reasons. Perhaps, the biggest reason is that it comes in a pack of two containers, giving you much more bang for your buck and the ability to store more ice cream away in these fantastic containers.

We rate this ice cream container very highly because of its slim and long design. Despite its slender size, you can actually store quite a bit of ice cream inside of it. It has a 1.5-quart capacity inside and this doubles to 3 quarts because this pack comes with two ice cream containers.

Even though these containers are made of a plastic design, this plastic is actually very durable and comes with an insulated design. This insulation does a fantastic job at keeping your ice cream as freezing cold as possible, which is exactly what you want out of these containers.

When full of ice cream inside, the size of these containers makes it easy to find a spot in your freezer. Since it is slender and long, it can easily be tucked into the pockets of your freezer door or it can be laid horizontally down and stacked on top of each other. They are not bulky at all and does a great job at efficiently storing your ice cream away while not taking up too much room.

Once you’ve gone through all of your ice cream, it’s easy to wash these containers as you can do so by hand or you can wash it in your dishwasher as these containers are dishwasher friendly.

What we liked: a real big benefit of this long and slim design is that it allows you to easily scoop your ice cream. The slenderness of this container makes it easy to scoop out your ice cream because it prevents you from scooping at different angles and makes it only possible to scoop it in one direction. This is also helpful because it will give you a good idea as to how much ice cream is left in the container.

What we didn’t like: the lid is something that we didn’t particularly like as we thought it was quite flimsy. We found it popped off after accidentally bumping the container while we were getting something else out of the freezer and so you’ll have to be careful with it.

The StarPack Home Ice Cream Freezer Storage Containers is the best ice cream container choice for people that are shopping on a tighter budget. This ice cream container is much different in its size and shape as the SUMO one but it still works like a charm.

This ice cream container also comes in a pack of two containers. This container is a size you may be more familiar with as it looks like any regular ice cream tub. They are approximately 5.3-inches tall and 4.7-inches wide and each container can fit roughly over one quart of ice cream.

The design of these ice cream containers is very simple and ordinary – it comes with a white tub and a red lid. The tub is made of BPA-free materials that are healthy to use and don’t contain any harmful plastics. The lid is made of durable, silicone material. The lids work really well and are fit very tightly over the ice cream containers.

When you don’t have any ice cream made at home and to store away, you can actually use these ice cream containers for other purposes as well. They act as great vessels for any soups you’ve made or leftover food. These containers are actually microwave friendly and so you can warm up your food in these containers using your microwave.

Lastly, these containers are a breeze to clean. Their materials prevent any food from really getting stubbornly stuck to them and can be washed either by hand or you can also get them clean by using your dishwasher. StarPack takes their customer service very seriously and say that if you experience any dissatisfaction with these ice cream containers, you will be entitled to a complete refund or replacement containers instead.

What we liked: we really love the versatility of these ice cream containers. We used them to store away our ice cream and when the winter season came and it got too cold to eat ice cream, we used these containers to store our homemade chicken noodle soup.

What we didn’t like: for a product at this affordable price and with so many great qualities, it was hard to find something we didn’t like. Perhaps, one thing that could improve is that it could hold slightly more ice cream in them.

If you’re not looking for an ice cream container option that comes with two containers and just want one that does a good job at storing lots of ice cream, the Tovolo Glide-A-Scoop Ice Cream Tub is probably your best bet. This ice cream tub is an excellent choice at keeping your ice cream freezing cold and at storing plenty of it as well.

This ice cream container is much different in that it is a very long container. To give you an idea, this container’s height is 4.1-inches but its length is 11.5-inches. That should give you a good mental image as to how long this ice cream container is. Despite being very long, it is still rather slender as it’s only 4-inches across.

This long ice cream container can hold 1.5-2 quarts of ice cream and should be more than enough for your ice cream storing needs. It’s constructed very well as it’s made of BPA-free plastic material that is double layered to add more insulation and keep your ice cream colder. This extra layer also does a fantastic job at keeping those annoying ice crystals, that form on the top layer of your ice cream, away.

The lid on this container is also very good and protects your ice cream well. The lid is airtight and does not allow any air or odors to seep in or out. The container also comes with a very handy, non-slip base that prevents it from sliding around in your freezer or on your kitchen countertop when you go to take it out.

A notable point of this ice cream container is that because of its slim size, it can easily fit into most freezers. If you have a fairly big freezer, you even might be able to fit this ice cream container on your freezer door for the best storage. One other thing that should be pointed out is that this container comes in three different colors, giving you some choices to choose from.

What we liked: we love that this ice cream container does well at packing in the ice cream and holding plenty of it to be stored away. Its slender size makes it that much easier to scoop out the ice cream because you only can scoop it one way.

What we didn’t like: if you have a particularly smaller freezer like we do, this ice cream container can be very difficult to store because it is so long. We had to re-position some of the things in our freezer just to make enough space for this ice cream container.

The BALCI - Premium Ice Cream Containers is another ice cream container option that offers multiple containers in this pack. With two ice cream containers, you can now make double the amount of ice cream you normally make and have the peace of mind knowing you’ll be able to store it all in your freezer with these containers.

These ice cream containers are tough in its design and are also free of BPA materials and the lid being made of silicone. What’s really good about these containers is that the inside of them are non-stick which makes them much easier to clean as you know there won’t be annoying bits of ice cream stuck to the container. The plastic material of these containers are also shatterproof and won’t crack, no matter how cold it is in your freezer.

You’ll get plenty of storage space with these ice cream containers. Each container is capable of holding one quart of ice cream. These containers aren’t very big either as each one is 5.5-inches tall and 4.7-inches wide at its widest point, which is at the lid. Speaking of the lid, it is made of silicone and is great at providing an airtight seal on your container.

Since the inside of these containers are non-stick, it is an absolute breeze to clean these containers. It won’t take you more than a minute to clean it by hand or if you’re feeling lazy, it is also dishwasher friendly. If at any point you’re unhappy with these containers, BALCI offers a lifetime warranty and will refund or replace the containers if you so choose.

What we liked: having a non-stick interior made our lives so much easier when it came to cleaning these containers. It is quick and easy to do so, including washing the flexible, silicone lid.

What we didn’t like: while these containers aren’t big in size, it can be difficult to find ample storage space for both containers in your freezer at the same time.

If you find that two ice cream containers just aren’t enough for you, maybe four will do the trick. With the Tovolo Sweet Treat Mini Tubs Set of 4, you get just that with four different containers for your ice cream.

With four different ice cream containers, you’re definitely going to have enough space for all of the ice cream you’ve made. Whether you plan on giving some away to your friends or family members or you plan to store it all away in your freezer, having four containers definitely makes it easier to have a place for all your ice cream.

Each of the four ice cream containers are capable of holding 6 ounces of ice cream in it, which really isn’t much space but will teach your kids the lesson of portion control. Each container is good in size and measures out to 5.5-inches in its height and 5.5-inches in its width. The containers are made of that all too familiar plastic materials that are BPA-free. This type of plastic material is perfect because they don’t shatter or break, no matter how cold it gets in your freezer.

These containers can be stacked in your freezer for easier storage. They are also very easy to clean, as is the case with all ice cream containers that are made of plastic and silicone materials and is dishwasher friendly.

The big benefit of having four ice cream containers for people is that you don’t have to store the same kind of ice cream in all containers. In fact, you can make four different flavors and batches of ice cream and store each flavor in these individual containers. This gives your family much more variety in terms of the ice cream they can eat and it also prevents you from ever having to buy four different kinds of ice cream at the store.

What we liked: these containers are not very big at all and thus, it is very easy to find a place for them in your freezer. Even if you plan on putting all four in your freezer, it really won’t be a big challenge to find enough space for all of them at the same time.

What we didn’t like: these containers are far too tiny to fit any real amount of ice cream in them. At only 6 ounces, it only translates to roughly 0.2 quarts of ice cream and we definitely think this needs to be far bigger in size.

Last on our list of the best ice cream containers is the Pinnacle Mercantile Plastic Containers. This set is unique because it contains the most ice cream containers in one pack with six.

The Pinnacle Mercantile Plastic Containers are also slightly different from the rest of the ones on our list. It’s more reminiscent of a jar than a container as the lid is a twist off one as opposed to one that pops on or off. The lid is also different in that it is not made of silicone, but rather is made of a plastic material.

The containers are made of HDPE which stands for high-density polyethylene. This material is great because while it does do an excellent job at storing your ice cream, it can also store other things like leftover food, soups, or even your arts and craft supplies.

In terms of the capacity of each container, you’ll be able to fit 16 ounces of ice cream in them which is roughly half a quart. In having six containers, you can dedicate two or three to ice cream and the rest to storing your other food as well. You don’t have to use all of them just for ice cream.

What we liked: in terms of sheer convenience and versatility, these containers offer the best of any one on our list simply because you get so many containers that you can do different things with. We have two containers for ice cream, three for our food and soups, and one where we keep random things for the house like coins, clips, and tape.

What we didn’t like: the only issue we had with these containers is that since the lid is a twist off, when keeping our ice cream in the freezer, it can be very difficult to open the lid since it’s frozen and is even painful on the hand and wrist.

Things to Consider Before Buying the Best Ice Cream Container

How Many Containers

Depending on how much ice cream you make at home, there are some ice cream containers that offer multiple containers. We have seen some that have two, four, or even six ice cream containers. There are many options for people that have families and you can easily find the right number of containers that works for you.

Capacity

The capacity of an ice cream container refers to how much ice cream you’ll be able to fit in them. Once again, this one can also vary depending on which product you buy. We have seen some with as little room as 0.2 quarts of ice cream to ones that can contain as much as 2 quarts of ice cream.

It’s important to note that the capacity of an ice cream container can also be a bit of a curse because the more capacity it has, the larger the container will be. This has implications for you especially if you don’t have plenty of space in your freezer to store it.

Size/Shape

Fortunately for you, the best ice cream containers come in all shapes and sizes and this is important for you because it can depend on the size of your freezer as well. Some ice cream containers are very economic with its shape and the space inside by offering a more longer than rounder shape. Ice cream containers that are longer can give people more options to store them, such as in your freezer door or inside the freezer.

Whereas, a rounder ice cream container looks much more like what you would expect an ice cream container to look like because it’s similar in shape to the ones you buy in store. These ice cream containers can be a bit trickier to store in your freezer, especially ones with a larger capacity, and so it’s important to ensure you have enough space in your freezer before purchasing it.

Cleaning It

Once you’re done eating all that ice cream, you’ll be happy to know that these ice cream containers offer a very easy way to clean them. Since they are usually made of non-stick materials, you can either wash it in your kitchen sink, by hand, using warm soapy water, or you can throw it in with the rest of your dishes in the dishwasher.

Final Thoughts

Ice cream is one of the best treats and dessert choices because of its simplicity and great taste. For many people, it’s much easier and cheaper to make a batch of ice cream at home rather than buying it at the store.

Now, with any one of the best ice cream containers, it is that much convenient to find a place to store your ice cream in. These ice cream containers are great at keeping your homemade ice cream fresh at all times in your freezer so that you and your family can enjoy it whenever you want.
5/5 - (2 votes)

Related Posts

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

user-avatar

Madison Taylor

Based in upstate New York, Madison is a devoted foodie and spends some of her time developing new re...

Pin It on Pinterest

Shares
Scroll to Top