As you can probably tell from the name, honey mustard is a mixture of honey and mustard, with about a one to one ratio between the two ingredients. It is a tangy but sweet sauce with a great deal of creaminess, which makes it a popular condiment people from all over the world. However, with all the options on the market today, it can be a challenge to find the best honey mustard brand to suit your needs and tastes.Today, we’ll be looking at the best types of honey mustard for all your cooking needs. We’ll look at what works best for a simple ham sandwich, what will complement a turkey or chicken, and some of the most unique varieties of this tasty condiment. By the time you get through all 10, you should have a good idea of which brand is best for you and your cooking.
The cranberry honey mustard by Dietz & Watson is our best pick because it adds an extra layer of flavor to your condiment and works well for various recipes, especially turkey sandwiches and salad dressings.
Billy Bee Original Honey Mustard stands out as our budget pick with its all-natural honey, suitability for a variety of diets, and its easy-to-use bottle that prevents a mess.
Table of Contents
- Quick Comparison: Top 10 Best Honey Mustard Brands
- 1. Dietz & Watson Deli Compliments Cranberry
- 2. Billy Bee Original Honey Mustard
- 3. Sweet Baby Ray’s Honey Mustard Dipping Sauce
- 4. Beaver Sweet Honey Mustard
- 5. Terrapin Ridge Farms Pecan Honey Mustard
- 6. Inglehoffer Honey Mustard
- 7. French’s Honey Mustard
- 8. Heinz Honey Mustard Dressing
- 9. French’s Squeeze Mustard Variety Pack
- 10. Sir Kensington’s Honey Mustard
- What to Know When Purchasing Honey Mustard
Quick Comparison: Top 10 Best Honey Mustard Brands
1. Dietz & Watson Deli Compliments Cranberry
The first honey mustard on our list is a special one, because, in addition to the traditional honey and mustard ingredients, it also offers a hint of cranberry for that extra tanginess. With this extra boost of flavor, you might find it tastes better than normal honey mustard on turkey sandwiches or as a glaze for ham. It takes the sweetness of honey mustard and adds a sourness that complements it perfectly in several dishes.
This cranberry honey mustard comes in 2 bottles of 11 ounces each. For most households, this will be more than enough to last weeks or even months in some families. The blend in this honey mustard includes sugar, vinegar, honey, mustard seed, cranberries, water, and several other spices and seasonings.As a unique honey mustard, this could be the best honey mustard brand for someone who wants a bit more zest and tanginess in their meals.
Billy Bee Original Honey Mustard comes in a 12-ounce bottle with a special squeezable design so you can unnecessary mess or spillage. It comes from a well-known honey brand that has been around since the 50s and is sourced only from Canadian beekeepers. It can be used in a variety of dishes to add a little extra sweetness and zest, such as baked chicken or dipping sauces.
This is one of the healthier honey mustards on the market, as it contains very little sodium, carbohydrates, and sugar. It also contains just 15 calories per serving, making it a great option if you’re looking to lose weight. It consists mostly of water, sugar, dextrose, mustard seed, honey, and vinegar, but does also contain artificial colorings and a few extra spices to liven things up.As one of the top manufacturers of honey, this honey mustard comes from a well-established company that knows what they are doing. It’s an option that’s well worth considering for your condiment needs.
3. Sweet Baby Ray’s Honey Mustard Dipping Sauce
Coming from a well-known brand, Sweet Baby Ray’s Honey Mustard Dipping Sauce is a condiment that has a lot going for it. While honey mustard might make you think of sandwiches and chicken nuggets, this formulation goes above and beyond. It can be used in a wide variety of dishes, from hot dogs and pork tenderloin to street corn, and more.
This honey mustard is higher in calories than other varieties, but also has very little saturated fat, few sugars, and few carbs. It’s largely made up of soybean oil, distilled vinegar, sugar, water, Dijon mustard, and honey. It also contains several seasonings, preservatives, and colorings to create a bright, vibrant color.This honey mustard from Sweet Baby Ray’s is a popular choice for a variety of dishes, from main meals to sides and dipping sauce. If you’re looking for a versatile ingredient to add to your kitchen, this could be the one for you.
4. Beaver Sweet Honey Mustard
If you’re someone who enjoys a little bit of spice to go with the sweetness and zest of honey mustard, this product from Beaver Brand might be your new favorite. It can be used for all sorts of dishes, including hot dogs, chicken nuggets, sandwiches, burgers, and salad dressings. It also comes in an ergonomically designed squeeze bottle, so it won’t make a mess, even if the kids get a hold of it.
This honey mustard is made from fresh ingredients, so you can be even more confident that it will give your dish the flavor and texture you’re looking for. It’s also healthy and ideal for many dietary needs, as it’s low-calorie, gluten-free, and vegetarian. It is also free from undesirable ingredients like cholesterol, trans fats, and preservatives, so fresh, healthy flavors shine through in every bite.Children may not love this mustard since it does pack in the spice, but for those who enjoy a bit of a kick, this is one of the best honey mustards you are going to come across. It even comes in a pack of six, so you can enjoy it for months to come.
5. Terrapin Ridge Farms Pecan Honey Mustard
Have you ever wanted to try a honey mustard with a truly unique flavor? This Terrapin Ridge Farms Pecan Honey Mustard is sure to deliver on that front. Another unique thing about this honey mustard is that it comes in a glass jar, which makes it a great option as a gift for someone who can never have enough condiments in their cupboard.
Each jar is 10.5 fluid ounces, and you can order one, three, or six at one time. The pecan flavor of this honey mustard works well with recipes like sweet potatoes, turkey breast, squash, and pork tenderloin. It’s also healthy, vegan-friendly and gluten-free, meeting a range of dietary requirements.As far as unique honey mustard goes, there are few that are going to surpass this option from Terrapin Ridge Farms. For those who enjoy nutty flavors, it might be even better than traditional mustards.
6. Inglehoffer Honey Mustard
This honey mustard from Inglehoffer comes in a pack of six 10.25-ounce bottles, each of which has an ergonomic squeeze tip to prevent spills. It has a sweet taste that pairs perfectly with meals such as hamburgers, sandwiches, salads, and more. This mustard has also been a gold medal winner at the Napa Valley world mustard championships, which may give you some insight into why it is so popular.This is one of the healthier honey mustards you will find, and it is created to meet all kinds of dietary needs. It is vegetarian, gluten-free, and contains very few calories. It also contains no trans fats, no preservatives, and no cholesterol. Its main ingredients include water, sugar, honey, wheat flour, and mustard seed, along with several spices to give it its unique flavor.
7. French’s Honey Mustard
French’s has been considered the best mustard in America for decades, and their honey mustard variety is no exception. It’s a sweet and tangy mustard that is made of top grade mustard seeds, real honey, distilled vinegar, water, sugar, and several spices. It comes in a squeezable bottle to prevent mess and spills.As far as the health benefits of this honey mustard go, it is suitable for many diets through being certified kosher and entirely gluten-free. It is free of high-fructose corn syrup but does contain some sugar, but in small amounts that won’t add up to much if you follow the serving suggestions. This delicious honey mustard can be used for all sorts of things, including as a dipping sauce, to make salad dressing, or on burgers and sandwiches.
8. Heinz Honey Mustard Dressing
The biggest thing that sets Heinz Honey Mustard Dressing apart from the rest is that rather than coming in a jar or a bottle, it comes in small single-serve packages like you might expect when you pull through the drive-through at a fast food restaurant. You get 200 packets that are easy to transport wherever you go. Those who are looking to watch their calorie intake will find it easier to track with this option, as the mustard comes in single serving-sized packets.
Heinz is well known in the condiment world, and their honey mustard contains quality ingredients including mustard, distilled white vinegar, honey, molasses, and a selection of spices and seasonings. However, this honey mustard does include high-fructose corn syrup and some preservatives to ensure it lasts. However, it has no fat or cholesterol and is a low-sodium product with only 15 calories in each packet.If you want a condiment that you can take with you or stash away for future use, this option from Heinz is likely one of the best you are going to come across. However, it may be less appropriate for bigger families or those of you looking to cook substantial meals with your honey mustard.
9. French’s Squeeze Mustard Variety Pack
When you order French’s Squeeze Mustard Variety Pack, you get that classic honey mustard that you’re looking for, but you also get the two other most popular mustards on the market: Dijon and spicy brown. The honey mustard uses real honey and is crafted from top-grade mustard seeds for a smooth condiment for sandwiches, dipping nuggets, and making salad dressings. The spicy brown is great for burgers and sandwiches, while the Dijon produces a distinctive flavor in many dishes.
With this variety pack, you’ll be happy to hear that its impressive ingredient list contains no colorants, dyes, artificial flavors, or high-fructose corn syrup. This option is also ideal for a variety of dietary needs, as all three mustards are kosher certified, non-GMO project certified, and gluten-free. With this selection, there’s something for everyone, so you can be sure that everyone is happy at a friends or family gathering.Want to try out a variety of mustards without needing to seek out several different brands? French’s makes that an option with this package deal that comes with the three most popular mustards around the world.
10. Sir Kensington’s Honey Mustard
Sir Kensington offers a selection of condiments that are certified kosher, non-GMO project verified, gluten-free, and paleo-friendly. With this honey mustard, you get top-quality ingredients such as fair-trade organic honey and grade A mustard seeds for a superior taste and texture. Sir Kensington’s also contains no filler ingredients such as preservatives or colorings and relies on real ingredients like spices, mustard seed, organic cane sugar, and vinegar.This is a popular honey mustard choice for those on low-carb diets and may also be a good option for you if you’re watching your weight. It has an authentic taste without relying on a ton of sugar or other ingredients that may be unhealthy for you. It is a bit zestier than it is sweet, so make sure that it fits your palate if you plan to go with this brand.
What to Know When Purchasing Honey Mustard
As we mentioned a little earlier, honey mustard’s name tells you all you need to know about its two key ingredients: honey and mustard. While other ingredients are usually added to the mustard and honey blend, it isn’t authentic honey mustard if it doesn’t contain these two ingredients. This type of mustard is often used as a dip for dishes like chicken strips and can also be used on sandwiches.
While this mustard has a touch of sweetness thanks to the honey, it also has a tanginess that gives your dishes a unique kick not found in other condiments. When purchasing honey mustard, there are a few things to be aware of to ensure you choose the right option for you.
All About the Different Kinds of Mustard
Even if you typically use simple yellow mustard for your sandwiches and recipes, sometimes there’s another mustard version that will better fit a dish. The reality is that there are dozens of different mustards on the market, and each of them offers something slightly different. We wanted to share what your options are and how you can use each one in the best way.
Regardless of the type of mustard, it is going to be made by grinding up mustard seeds and mixing them into some kind of liquid. This is the process that helps release the oils and enzymes in the mustard seed to offer a great flavor.
Using a low-acid liquid like water with the mustard seed will create hotter mustard, but it is more likely to lose its potency quickly. On the other hand, high-acid liquids such as vinegar keep the heat down but ensure the pungency sticks around for a longer time.
Mustard seeds come in several varieties, including black, brown, and yellow. Yellow mustard seeds are the most commonly used and also happen to offer the mildest flavor. There is more flavor with black and brown seeds, which may be used along with yellow seeds to create certain mustard varieties.
The most classic types of mustard are the following:
- Yellow – A mild mustard popular in the United States that has a bold yellow color. You’ll see this mustard in most households, and it’s often referred to simply as “mustard.”
- Dijon – This is a classic French mustard that has been produced since the 1850s. Today’s version uses white wine and has a consistency similar to yellow mustard, but with a sharper flavor.
- Spicy Brown – Using coarser seeds than Dijon or yellow mustard, this option includes brown mustard seeds. It has a deep flavor and more heat, which makes it popular in delis and at hot dog carts.
There is also a selection of mustards beyond Dijon that use wine in their creation. Some examples include white burgundy mustard, champagne mustard, and pinot noir mustard. If you are already a fan of Dijon mustard, these varieties are a great choice for something similar with a different taste.
Coarse mustards are also popular in some areas and have a chunky grind with a great deal of texture and flavor. Some of the mustards that fall into this category include stone ground mustard, whole-grain whiskey mustard, creole mustard, whole-grain stout mustard, and whole-grain Dijon mustard. There are also some spicy brown mustards that fit into this category.
In addition, there are international mustards with unique tastes and textures, including:
- Chinese – An extremely hot mustard that is typically used for egg rolls and similar dishes.
- English – A spicy mustard with a bright yellow color but a much sharper bite and heat.
- German – Similar to Dijon but with additional heat and intended for pretzels.
Another category is sweet mustard, which is where you will find honey mustard, brown sugar mustard, honey Dijon mustard, and others. There are several differences between these mustard types, with some having an intense maple flavor and others being quite spicy. However, they all have a nice tang with a touch of sweetness that works well on sandwiches.
These are the main categories of mustards, but there are additional options you may see from time to time. For example, horseradish mustard and spicier mustards that use habanero, Sriracha, and more. If you decide to make your own mustard, you can add in whatever extra ingredients suit your tastes to create your own unique condiment to go with your favorite foods.
Potential Uses for Honey Mustard
Many people see honey mustard as a condiment that can only be used in a limited number of ways, such as for a condiment on a sandwich or a dipping sauce for fried foods. However, there are many other ways to use honey mustard if you aren’t afraid to get a bit creative. We wanted to share a few of the top recipes that make use of the best honey mustard brands to liven up dishes you may not have thought about.
A few unique ways to use honey mustard include:
- As a marinade or spread added to pork or chicken while it cooks
- As an additional item on a cheese board that compliments buttery, creamy cheeses
- Spread onto salmon filets cooked under the broiler in your oven
- Tossed with sweet potatoes, carrots, and parsnips before roasting
- As a dipping sauce for snacks like pretzels, popcorn, and dried fruit
- Combined with mayo or Greek yogurt for dipping chicken nuggets or tenders
- As an addition to vinaigrette for extra emulsification and sweetness
This is a versatile condiment that can be used in all sorts of different recipes, so don’t be afraid to experiment and find your favorite ways to use it. The inclusion of honey with mustard and warm spices works well for many dishes. Its high sugar content will deepen the flavors of your dish and makes caramelization possible, giving you even more options to work with.
How to Make and Store Honey Mustard
There are many different brands that offer honey mustard, as you can see above. However, it can also be created in your own kitchen if you’d prefer to go the DIY route. Below, we’ll look at one recipe for honey mustard and then look at how you should store it to keep it in good condition for as long as possible.
When making your own creamy, sweet, and tangy honey mustard, you’ll need the following ingredients:
- ½ cup of mayonnaise
- 3 tablespoons of honey
- 1 tablespoon of yellow mustard
- 1 tablespoon of Dijon mustard
- 1 teaspoon of apple cider vinegar
- 1/8 teaspoon of salt
- 1/8 teaspoon of garlic powder
- 1/8 teaspoon of paprika
- Pepper to taste
Even if you aren’t much of a cook, this is a recipe that you can easily whip up in no time. All you need to do is take all of the above ingredients and combine them into a bowl, and then stir it all together until the mixture is smooth.
… And that’s it! In just a few minutes you’ve made your very own homemade honey mustard. It can be used immediately, or you can keep it in your fridge for later use.
As far as the nutritional value of this honey mustard goes, a two-tablespoon serving has about 170 calories, 10 grams of carbohydrates, and less than a gram of protein. This honey mustard also has around 15 grams of fat, 282 milligrams of sodium, and a touch of dietary fiber.
If you make your own homemade honey mustard, storing it in the refrigerator is a must. It will likely not last as long as honey mustard you buy at the store and should be used within four or five days. You can always adjust the ingredients you use to make sure the amount you have will be used up in that time, however.
Honey mustard is a popular condiment that can be used in many ways and is a staple of many households as a dipping sauce or sandwich ingredient. As you’d expect, its two key ingredients are honey and mustard, but it can also include all sorts of spices and other ingredients to suit your tastes and meals.
Now that you know all you need to know about honey mustard, you should be ready to decide on the best honey mustard brand for your own home. Don’t be afraid to try a few options to see which one is your favorite; you might surprise yourself!