Best Butter Keeper

The 10 Best Butter Keepers in 2018

Fresh, spreadable butter with a hot toast first thing in the morning can be a pleasant start to your day. Unfortunately, many of us are in a rush in the mornings and have to do with unpleasant refrigerated butter that rolls a tear in our bread slice.

Many people don’t care much about their daily toast and butter, but why not fix this tiny problem to enjoy the little joys in life? The solution to cold, hard butter that refuses to spread is a butter keeper. A butter keeper helps to keep the butter stick fresh and spreadable at room temperature.  

If you’re tired of refrigerated butter, you may consider purchasing a butter keeper. There are a plethora of butter keepers in the market today. To help you choose the right one, we have reviewed the best butter keepers available in the market at present.

​Best Pick

The Original Butter Bell Crock by L. Tremain

If your main purpose while purchasing a butter keeper is to keep the butter fresh and spreadable at all time, we recommend the Original Butter Bell Crock by L. Tremain, Antique Collection. It is not only practical to use but also aesthetically pleasing.

​Budget Pick

Arc International Luminarc Cow Butter Dish

If you are looking for a butter keeper that is convenient to use, is large enough to store a good amount of butter without costing too much, we recommend the Arc International Luminarc Cow Butter Dish. It is 100% hygienic and washes resistant.


1. ​The Original Butter Bell Crock by L. Tremain

The L.Tremain butter bell crock is the new and improved version of the original French butter crock. Its design features a bell-shaped lead and a crock as the bottom. The crock is made from highly durable new bone china clay that ensures that the butter inside the crock remains fresh and soft for at least 30 days.

The butter is kept inside the inverted bell-shaped lid and the cold water kept in the base of the crock ensures the flavor and freshness of it by making the butter keeper airtight. The water has to be removed in 2-3 days to maintain the fresh flavor of the butter. 

The crock is conveniently sized and can store up to one stick of butter. The original bell butter crock can be a nice addition to your kitchen décor. It can add a touch of rustic charm to your kitchen with its design. It comes in nine different shades of color. The durable new bone china of the crock makes it scratch resistant. All in all, the original bell butter crock is a nice kitchen gadget that will enhance your kitchen décor.

​Pros

  • check
    Can keep butter fresh and soft for 30 days
  • check
    Comes in different shades
  • check
    Is durable and dishwasher safe
  • check
    Free of cadmium and lead
  • check
    Can offer a rustic charm to your kitchen décor
  • check
    Can also be used to serve butter

​Cons

  • check
    The butter may fall into the water in some cases
  • check
    Need to be kept away from sunlight and heat
  • check
    There are other keepers with more storage capacity

2. Arc International Luminarc Cow Butter Dish

Luminarc cow butter dish is made of highly durable thick glass. The measurement of one butter dish is 6-1/2 by 2-3/4-inch. It is 100 percent hygienic and is wash resistant. The glass of the dish is heavy, thick and fully tempered, that is the glass will not crack or damage at different temperatures.

The lid can have more than one use; it can be filled with crushed ice and be kept under the bottom of the dish to keep the butter inside cool and fresh over a holiday meal or extended buffet meal. It is easy to lift the lead because of the detailed cow design on it.

The butter dish has a sufficient enough room to accommodate two sticks of butter or 8 ounces of European style butter. If you are looking for an easy to use butter dish with sufficient storage capacity then you can consider purchasing this one.

​Pros

  • check
    Is wash resistant, and hygienic
  • check
    Is large enough to store a good amount of butter
  • check
    The Lid has many uses
  • check
    Is well made, thick and durable
  • check
    Transparent glass makes it easy to check how much butter is left

​Cons

  • check
    The glass might get scratches
  • check
    Has no knob, making it slightly difficult to take off the lid

3. Now Designs Square Butter Dish

The square butter dish measures 4.5 inches wide 4.5 inches long and stands 4 inches tall. It is perfect for storing square shaped butter. It can also store bread spreads other than butter. This dish is dish wash resistant and microwave safe.

The square butter dish is stoneware made. Therefore it is sturdy and durable. It also has a knob on the lid, making it convenient for lifting. It offers a contemporary look to your kitchen décor with its design. It also comes in five different shades, so if you are considering purchasing this you will have options.

​Pros

  • check
    Is dish wash and microwave safe
  • check
    Has a knob for easy lifting
  • check
    Is well made and durable
  • check
    Can be used to store other bread spreads

​Cons

  • check
    ​Not enough storage capacity
  • check
    ​The butter may smear on the sides of the lid

4. Butter Bay American Made Butter Keeper

The Butter Bay butter keeper has a unique design that brings a new look to the French butter crock. Just like the French butter crock, its design features two items, a butter bay that holds the butter upside down and a basin in which water is kept to make an airtight seal.

Unlike the butter crock, the butter bay is supposed to hold a whole cube of butter. Thus it has more storage capacity and seating the butter in the bay is not a messy task. You can watch an instructional video on how to use the butter bay.

The butter bay keeps the butter fresh and spreadable for three weeks. But the water in the basin has to be changed every 3-4 days. You will be able to enjoy fresh spreadable butter at any hour of the day without refrigerating it by using the butter bay. It is dishwasher safe. 

The butter bay is 100% American made. The slip-cast method is used to make it and it is finished by hand in a factory built in the early 1900s. It is constructed from durable stoneware and is lead and cadmium free. This comes in five fashionable colors, so you can choose one according to your kitchen décor.

​Pros

  • check
    Keeps the butter fresh and spreadable for three weeks
  • check
    Unique design offers to store a whole cube of butter without making a mess
  • check
    Available in five different shades
  • check
    Cadmium and lead-free
  • check
    ​Dishwasher safe
  • check
    ​No refrigeration needed to keep butter fresh

​Cons

  • check
    The butter may fall off the bay unless it is properly seated
  • check
    The design is delicate and sometimes the bay comes in a smaller size than advertised

5. Le Creuset Stoneware Butter Crock

The Le Creuset butter crock inspired from the original crock features a classic design. It is an airtight vessel that keeps the butter fresh and spreadable without melting at room temperature. With this, you can say goodbye to flattened flaky croissants and torn toasts.

The bell can store more than one stick of butter. Pre-softened butter should be packed in the bell with a spoon. The crock should be filled with cold water up to the water line. The water should be changed every 3-4 days to keep the butter fresh.

The crock is made of high fired stoneware that is dense enough to block moisture and prevent cracking. The high-quality enamel exterior protects it from scratches and stains from metal utensils. The interior is non-porous enamel glazed which releases food easily for a quick clean up. It is also dishwasher safe.

The crock comes in a few bold colors that match other Le Creuset stoneware. It comes with a lifetime warranty, so it's a win-win situation for you if you decide to purchase it.

​Pros

  • check
    High fired dense stoneware protects the vessel from cracking, scratches and stains
  • check
    Is dishwasher safe and has a lifetime warranty
  • check
    Comes in a few different shades
  • check
    Is resistant to odor absorption
  • check
    Non-porous enamel glazed interior helps in quick clean up
  • check
    There is a water line inside the crock that indicates the amount of water needed to be poured inside

​Cons

  • check
    Butter may fall into water if not properly packed in the bell

6. Trudeau 09607081A Porcelain Butter Boat

The design of the Trudeau Butter boat is different from the usual butter crock but it uses the same mechanism. It features a dual chamber in which the butter is kept on the boat and the cold water in the basin under it.

It keeps the butter soft and spreadable at room temperature for weeks. Removing water after 3-4 days from the crock can become a tedious task but with the butter boat's dual chamber design of the butter, the boat makes it easy to swap out the water. 

Also storing the butter in the butter boat is not a messy task as the butter stick can simply be kept on the boat and covered with a lid. The butter boat comes in classic white that can blend in with any kitchen décor. It is made of high-quality glazed porcelain and is thus dishwasher safe.

​Pros

  • check
    Made of high-quality porcelain
  • check
    Is dishwasher safe
  • check
    Easy to use
  • check
    Can store one stick of butter for weeks

​Cons

  • check
    The lid does is not a tight fit, so it is not airtight

7. Svebake Butter Dish

If you are tired of fragile ceramic or glass made glass dish you may consider purchasing the Svebake Butter Dish. It is an enamel butter dish which is highly durable and ensures long-lasting beauty. It is a classic white butter dish with a beech wood lid. It offers an exquisite look with its cute size and contemporary yet vintage design.

The Svebake Butter Dish features a dual chambered design with a butter boat and basin to store cold water. The butter boat has a large enough capacity to store about two sticks of butter. The enamel glaze makes it easy to clean up with water, but it is not dishwasher safe with the lid on.

You can also consider gifting someone with this butter dish. Because not only is the design cute, it is multifunctional and convenient. The butter boat can store both block and cream butter without melting it. The beech wood lid can also be used as a cutting board.

​Pros

  • check
     Large enough for storing 2 sticks of butter
  • check
    Can store both block and cream butter
  • check
    Is convenient and multifunctional
  • check
    Made of durable enamel

​Cons

  • check
    Can chip away easily
  • check
    The Lid is not a snug fit after wash
  • check
    Is not dish wash safe with the lid on

8. OXO Good Grips Butter Dish

The OXO Good Grips Butter Dish features a stainless steel base and a clear plastic lid. It is easy enough to use both at the dinner table and the kitchen. The clear lid is easy to remove and does not slide off.

The dish is just as the name suggests, it has two stoppers on both sides that grips the butter and prevents it from sliding off the dish while cutting. It can also store long or short butter and is dishwasher safe. You can consider purchasing this as it is super convenient to use.

​Pros

  • check
    Prevents butter from sliding off with stoppers
  • check
    Clear wide butter dish
  • check
    Is dishwasher safe
  • check
    Can store long or short butter

​Cons

  • check
    The lid is not secured firmly with the base

9. My Gift Decorative White Ceramic Lidded Butter Dish

A butter keeper that is ideal for serving is the My Gift Decorative White Ceramic Lidded Butter Dish. It comes with a serving knife, knife holder and lid on top, making it super convenient for both serving and storing butter.

The design of this dish is elegant and will be a great addition to your countertop or dining table. It can store both butter and margarine. The ceramic domes lid is large and wide enough so that it won’t stick to the butter. You can consider purchasing this stylish dish that can safely store your butter and is easily accessible.

​Pros

  • check
    Ideal for both serving and storing
  • check
    Comes with matching serving knife and knife holder
  • check
    Comes with a cleaning towel
  • check
    Easily accessible because of the top lid
  • check
    The lid does not stick to the butter

​Cons

  • check
    Not an airtight vessel

​10. Sweese 3109 Porcelain Butter Keeper Crock

The Sweese Porcelain Butter Keeper Crock is a French butter dish that ensures fresh, spreadable butter at hand at all times. The airtight vessel keeps butter fresh for a month. It can store more than one stick of soft butter, sometimes even one and a half stick of butter depending on how you press it.

If you are always confused about how much water needs to be poured into the crock, your problem can be solved by using this keeper as its crock comes with a fill line. The water should be replaced every 2-3 days. It is easy to clean and practical to use. It is dishwasher safe.

The Sweese Butter Keeper crock is made of highly durable porcelain that is non-toxic and lead-free. This dish also comes with a 30-day non-chip warranty so, if anything goes wrong with your product you can get a refund or replacement. It is well made and comes in different shades of colors; you can pick any to match with your kitchen décor.

​Pros

  • check
    Keeps butter fresh and spreadable for a month
  • check
    Stores more than one stick butter
  • check
    Comes with a fill line
  • check
    Comes with a 30-day non-chip warranty
  • check
    Made of high-grade porcelain
  • check
    Comes in various shades
  • check
    Is dishwasher safe

​Cons

  • check
    Crock needs to be kept away from heat
  • check
    Butter can fall into the water if not pressed into the bell properly

Things to consider before buying the best butter keeper

To get the best out of a product it is important to know about all the features and types of that product. If you’re planning to purchase a butter keeper you must keep in mind a few things to choose the best butter keeper to fit your needs.

Size 

Butter keepers come in different sizes and shapes. The storing capacity of each butter keepers is thus different. If you rarely use butter it is best to get a butter keeper that stores less butter, say a stick of butter.  Again if you have a big family and frequently use butter it is best to get a keeper that can store more than one stick of butter.

Design

If you want to bring a vintage look to your kitchen décor you can purchase a butter keeper designed to emulate the original French butter crock. If you want more of a contemporary look you can purchase a butter boat keeper or a butter bay. Again, if you want more of a practical design you can opt for a transparent keeper made of glass or plastic.

There are a plethora of designs to choose from, but if you care about keeping the butter fresh and spreadable at room temperature, it is best to purchase a butter keeper designed to have an airtight seal.

Construction

Before purchasing a butter keeper it is important to keep in mind, how the butter keepers are constructed and what materials are used

A butter keeper can be constructed featuring various designs, using different materials. It is important to know which material used makes the keeper durable and easy to wash. For health safety, you must make sure the butter keeper you are purchasing is free of lead, cadmium and other non-toxic materials.

To make an informed decision, you must keep these features in mind and also compare different products to get a clear idea about the price, design, and quality.

Conclusion

It is normal to get befuddled while purchasing the right butter keeper, as there are plenty of options available. But to pick the best butter keeper, you will have to make a clear and informed decision.

If you are a first-time buyer, you can go for a simply designed Arc International Luminarc Cow Butter Dish. If you want to purchase a butter keeper that is aesthetically pleasing and will keep your butter fresh and soft, you can go for the Original Butter Bell Crock by L. Tremain or Svebake Butter Dish.

Whatever decision you make, you should consider all the aspects and features of the butter keeper before purchasing it.
The 10 Best Butter Keepers in 2018
5 (100%) 1 vote