The 10 Best Silicone Baking Mats in 2018

One thing that is a serious issue when it comes to baking is the baked goods being stuck to the baking tray. There is nothing more heartbreaking for a baker than to watch the perfectly shaped cookies losing their edges and corners when they are being taken off the baking tray, and if you have experienced the same disappointment, then you would be glad that you came to read this article where we will introduce you to a baking tool that will fix this problem like magic.

The baking essential that we are going to look into today is called a silicone baking mat and you can lay it down on your baking pan or tray to provide a non-stick surface that is not only superior in heat resistance and non-sticky properties but is also reusable and safe to your health. We know that many people might have suggested you go for parchment papers and cooking spray to make your baking surface non-sticky, but parchment papers are wasteful, and annoying at times when you are in a hurry and have to cut out the right size and shape to fit your baking surface, whereas cooking spray can give your baked goods a greasy texture if it is used excessively.

In comparison, silicone baking mats are incredibly easy to clean, can be used again and again until you have baked to your heart’s content, and does not leave any unpleasant flavor or texture to your baked goodies. As much as we think having a silicone baking mat is one of the basic requirements for a serious baker, we also warn you to not settle for the first silicone baking mat that you come across in the market since they vary greatly in shape, size, and quality.

And that is why we have chosen the best silicone baking mats that are available on the market today, and have brought them together in this article where we will look at each one of them so that you can make an informed decision and choose the perfect one for your baking adventures.

​Best Pick

KITZINI Silicone Baking Mat

With an attractive design and a fiberglass core combined with a high heat-resistant silicone, this set of two differently colored silicone baking mats from KITZINI would not disappoint you. Its superior quality and design have earned it the best pick positron on our list so be sure to check out its in-depth description in the next section!

​Budget Pick

Artisan Silicone Baking Mat

Although a silicone baking mat is a reusable baking item, you would not want to spend a lot on buying one especially if you are a first-time user of this product. That is why we have selected a budget pick product for you which offers you great performance and quality at a relatively low price.


1. ​KITZINI Silicone Baking Mat

This set of baking mats include two silicone baking mats that have a classy woven pattern bordered with a red and blue lining. The silicone that has been used to make this is heat resistant up to 450 degrees F, which means you can use it in your high heat oven.

The mat’s surface ensures that the heat is evenly spread out, preventing your bakery items from being baked unevenly. The professional grade silicone of this mat has been strengthened by a core that is made of fiberglass which gives you both flexibility and durability at the same time. The mat has a standard size of 16.5" x 11 5/8" which will easily fit onto any standard size baking trays. 

Not only is this baking mat able to withstand high temperatures, it can also go into your freezer for storing your dough and unbaked cookies, and can stay at a temperature that is as low as minus 40 degrees F without becoming damaged. Since the mat is non-sticky on its own, you can use it to bake without using extra butter or cooking spray which allows you to cook a healthy, low-calorie baked food, and also helps you to clean up the mat with minimal mess and work. 

This mat is not only suitable for making pastries and cookies, but it can also be used to knead dough on it, as well as for baking vegetables and chicken, and for making sweet items such as toffee, caramel, and lollipops. A silicone baking mat that is so versatile would surely be a valuable addition to your kitchen.

​Pros

  • check
    The set includes two silicone baking mats that have differently colored borders
  • check
    The mat is heat resistant up to 450 degrees F, and can also withstand low temperatures up to minus 40 degrees F in the freezer
  • check
    It is suitable for versatile uses such as baking savory and sweet items, and as a surface for kneading a dough
  • check
    The mat has an effective non-sticky surface so you can slide the baked items effortlessly from the baking pan without using greasing or cooking spray
  • check
    It can be easily cleaned and reused

​Cons

  • check
    Both the mats in the set are of the same size but some people might want a different size of the mat to fit their baking pans

2. Artisan Silicone Baking Mat

As the name of the brand suggests, this baking mat set is a true friend of an artisan baker. The set includes two semi-transparent silicone baking mats with a red border which goes very well with any elegant patisserie interior.

The mats also boast of a fiberglass that has been woven into a strong, durable and flexible core which makes allows you to roll and bend the mat any way you want to. The mats measure 11 x 16.5 inches each, and they are made of silicone that is free of PFOA and BPA, maintain a high standard of food safety. 

When it comes to baking, this mat can endure temperatures as high as 480 degrees F, but that it is not limited to oven and toaster uses. The mat can also be used to make frozen or cold desserts such as chocolate coated strawberries, frozen blueberries, etc. since the mat can withstand low temperatures up to minus 40 degrees F, and will also enable you to take out the desserts smoothly without causing any damage to the structure of the desserts and fruits.

This mat's performance will shine brightly even when it comes to baking savory dishes such as making roasted potatoes or chicken breasts and hence is a great choice for anyone who wants a non-sticky surface for all their baking needs. After it has been used, the mat can be easily cleaned by simply wiping it using a wet cloth and then stored in its flat form or by rolling it into a compact form.

​Pros

  • check
    The set includes two mats with an elegant semi-transparent surface and a red border
  • check
    It can withstand temperatures from minus 40 degrees F to 480 degrees F
  • check
    It can be safely used in the microwave, toaster oven, and the freezer so you can make frozen and baked dishes using this mat
  • check
    It has a fiberglass core which makes it flexible and durable
  • check
    It can be easily cleaned by wiping with a wet cloth

​Cons

  • check
    It has to be handled with care and some precautionary measures have to be followed to ensure its longevity

3. Silpat Premium Non-Stick Silicone Baking Mat

If you are involved with the professional bakeries, you would know that Silpat is a name that bakers use instead of a silicone baking mat when they are talking about one. And it comes as no surprise that a company that has been built by a person who was a passionate baker himself, and which has been making reliable baking tools for a very long time, would have such a prestigious position in the world of baking.

Hence this list would be incomplete without this silicone baking mat from Silpat that has been loved by its users and is still known to be one of the best when it comes to baking. This baking mat has a size of 11-5/8" x 16-1/2", which is also known as the standard half-sheet size, and has curved corner edges which makes it easy to lift it up from the baking tray. 

It can be used within the temperature range of -40° F to 482° F, helping you to make baked and frozen dishes alike. The quality of the mat is top-notch as it combines high-quality food grade silicone with a fiberglass mesh to provide you with an excellent non-sticky surface that promotes even browning and baking.

It also has a superior durability which allows you to use it for at least 2000 to 3000 times of baking depending on how well you use it. If you are a professional baker or a serious home baker, who is looking for a high quality and authentic silicone baking mat, then this mat from Silpat would be one of the best options for you.

​Pros

  • check
    Silpat silicone baking mat is a very renowned product that has been used by professional bakers for many years
  • check
    It can be used in the freezer as well as in the oven
  • check
    It has curved corners for the mat to be easily removed from the baking pan

​Cons

  • check
    ​It is sold as a single product instead of a set

4. AmazonBasics Silicone Baking Mat

If simplicity is something that you prefer around your home, then this set of two silicone baking mats from AmazonBasics might be a baking mat that you would want to look into. Both mats come in a size of 11.6 X 16.5 inches and have dark grey borders that are easy to match with any kitchen interior.

The mats can withstand high temperatures of 480 degrees F and will give you a non-stick surface that is great for any type of sweet or savory baking. 

One feature that we especially love about this silicone baking mat is that it is strong enough to withstand the use of metal spatula and utensils, which is usually a no-no for most silicone baking mats. Due to its high durability, the mat can also be washed in the top rack of your dishwasher and saves you from the trouble of having to clean it out with your hands.

​Pros

  • check
    The mat has a simple design
  • check
    The set includes two mats of the same size
  • check
    It can withstand the use of metal spatula and utensils
  • check
    It can be washed in the top rack of your dishwasher

​Cons

  • check
    The design might seem to be too plain to some users

5. Velesco Silicone Baking Mat

If you do a lot of baking then you need to check out this set of silicone baking mat from Velesco that includes not only one but three mats of the same size and thickness. Each of the mats has a size of 11 5/8" x 16 1/2" and a thickness of 0.75 mm and will be a perfect fit for the standard baking sheets that are used at your homes.

The mats are made of a silicone-fiberglass hybrid material and this provides an excellent nonstick surface and a high durability. You can use it in the freezer, microwave, and toaster oven, since it can withstand temperatures within the range of minus 40 degrees F to 480 degrees F. 

You can also use it on your kitchen table for rolling and kneading your dough and thanks to the non-stick surface of the mat, the dough will come off smoothly every time. Another aspect of the mat that we are in love with is the fact that it can be washed in the dishwasher and cuts down your cleaning time after baking is complete.

​Pros

  • check
    Three mats in a set so you do not have to buy them separately
  • check
    The mat can withstand temperatures within the range of -40 degrees F to 480 degrees F so it can go into the freezer, microwave, and toaster oven
  • check
    You can use it as a non-stick surface for rolling and kneading your dough
  • check
    It can be washed in the dishwasher

​Cons

  • check
    All three mats are of the same size and have the same appearance  

6. Silchef Silicone 3 Piece Non-Stick Baking Mats

There are several things that set this silicone baking mat apart from the others. First of all, the set includes three mats, two of which have the half-sheet size, and one which has a quarter-sheet size. The mats having different sizes means that you can use them for different purposes, for example, you can use the small one in your toaster oven, without having to cut the big one into a smaller shape.

The mats also come in three different colors, green, red, and yellow, which is great for identification, for example, if you want a difference between the mat that you use for savory dishes, and the one that you use for sweet pastries. 

Another feature of this mat that we absolutely love is the fact the mat comes with measurement markings, so you set the baking items such as cookies and macaroons in neat rows on the mat. The mats are non-stick so anything you bake on it will slide right off smoothly after the baking is complete, and you can clean the mat easily on the top rack of your dishwasher.

​Pros

  • check
    The set consists of three mats in total, two which have a half-sheet size, and one that has a quarter sheet size
  • check
    The mats are rimmed with differently colored borders so it is easy to specify the mats for separate types of uses
  • check
    The mats come with measurement markings which you can use as a guide when laying down items in neat rows
  • check
    The mat can be washed in the top rack of the dishwasher

​Cons

  • check
    If you are looking for a set of identical mats, then this might not be the best choice for you

7. Jollylife Silicone Healthy Cooking Baking Mat

Whereas the other mats on this list are flat, this one is not, and comes with a raised texture which gives you a unique advantage in cooking and baking. When it comes to roasting and baking, an alternative to silicone baking mats can be parchment papers, and many people prefer to use it because parchment papers give a crispier finish compared to silicone mats.

If you are looking for a silicone baking mat that can help you achieve similar crispy results, then look no more since this mat has been designed in a special way to do exactly that! The pyramid-like structures on the mat allow air flow to move around the food, and transfers heat by convection, as the grease and oils drip down below. 

This gives your food such as biscuits and bacon a crispy finish, as well as makes them healthier by cutting down the fat content of the food. Another amazing thing about this design is that you can use the reverse side of the mat, which has a ridged square texture and acts like a food mold for items such as waffles and cookies.

This innovatively designed mat measures 11.5 x 16 inches, and can withstand temperatures within the range of -40 degrees F to 446 degrees F. If you want the mat to fit a smaller baking sheet, then you can cut the mat to any shape and size you desire and use it, since the mat does not contain any toxic plastic materials.

​Pros

  • check
    The mat can be cut into any shape and size that is convenient for you
  • check
    It has small raised pyramid shapes all over the surface, which helps in air circulation, making your food crispier and healthier
  • check
    It can be rolled for neat and compact storage
  • check
    The reverse side of the mat is designed with square ridges so this side can be used as a food mold for waffles and other similar items
  • check
    The mat can withstand temperatures within the range of -40 degrees F to 446 degrees F

​Cons

  • check
    If your batter or dough is very delicate, it might be affected by the patterns on the surface of the mat

8. Vremi 3 Piece Silicone Baking Mat Set

This set is great for anyone who wants flexibility when it comes to size and design. For example, you might want a smaller baking mat for your small toaster oven, or want to bake with your children at home and might colorful mats that would make baking fun for your children.

This set from Vremi consists of three baking mats, two of which have the standard half-sheet size, and one has a quarter-sheet size. The mats come with rims of three different colors, blue, red, and green, to add color to your kitchen. The mats are made by combining transparent fiberglass and food-grade silicone which makes the mats nonstick, resistant to hot and cold temperatures, flexible, and tear-resistant. 

You can lay them flat to bake macaroons and cookies in the oven, to freeze your fruits in minus 40 degrees F, or roll them up to store them in a compact form. The baking mats are very easy to clean since they do not need to even go into the dishwasher, you can clean them simply by washing them with warm water and soap.

​Pros

  • check
    The set consists of two half-sheet size mats and one quarter-sheet size mat which gives you flexibility in size
  • check
    The mats are of different colors which makes your kitchen vibrant and makes it fun to bake with your children
  • check
    They are nonstick so the cookies will come off easily and they are also easy to clean with hands
  • check
    They are flexible yet tear-resistant so you can roll them up for compact storage

​Cons

  • check
    They are not safe to be washed in the dishwasher

9. Silpat Perfect Cookie Baking Mat

As we have mentioned before, Silpat is a brand name that is so popular when it comes to silicone baking mats that in many professional bakeries and patisseries, silicone baking mats are referred to as Silpats. They have been in this market for a long time and their products prove that they understand the needs of avid bakers very well.

If you love baking cookies, you would know that it is difficult to guess where would be the right place to place the cookie dough on your baking sheet. To assist you in your cookie baking, this mat comes with indentations that clearly guide you in where to place your cookie dough. 

Not only does this makes the cookie baking process a whole lot easier, it helps you to make all of your cookies the same size and shape, and helps you to keep track of how many cookies you have baked. This is very useful when you have to bake cookies for a party where you would want to make sure that each of your guests gets a cookie, or at a professional setting where keeping an accurate record of the production is a very important aspect of the whole business.

If you use this mat, you would not need to spray any cooking oil or use parchment paper, which saves time, cuts down on the cost, prevents wastage and keeps the flavors and taste of the cookies unaffected. Since the mat is nonstick, the cookies you bake will come off very easily from the mat, which helps you in keeping the shape and the texture of the cookies intact.

Since Silpat uses top-quality silicone in making their mats, the mat ensures even distribution of heat to all of the cookies, which makes sure that none of your cookies are under baked or burnt. If you are a serious cookie maker or a beginner who wants to bake cookies like a pro, this is a product that you would not want to miss out on.

​Pros

  • check
    This mat has been made by Silpat which is a very renowned company when it comes to baking mats and has a great reputation regarding the quality
  • check
    The mat has a nonstick surface so your cookies would come off smoothly which helps to keep the shape and texture of the cookies intact
  • check
    The mat has been designed with circular indentations which helps you to make 13 cookies that are of the same size and shape

​Cons

  • check
    The mat is sold as a single mat instead of a set so you would have to buy them separately if you want more than one

​10. X-Chef Silicone Baking Mats

This set of silicone baking mat consists of three identical mats that have a size of 16.5 X 11.6 inches and are extremely durable and flexible at the same time. The middle surface of the mat has been designed with red borders and looks great even when the mat is lying flat on the countertop.

When they are placed on the countertop, they have an anti-slip surface which holds them securely onto the table surface, making them a great surface for shaping and rolling your bread or cookie dough. The mat can withstand high temperatures up to 480 degrees F and can be used to bake versatile dishes and pastries.

 If you are roasting something that is extra-messy, for example, a marinated chicken breast with vegetables, the cleanup be exhausting, but not if you cover the baking sheet with this silicone mat. Since the mat is nonstick, you can easily wipe out any kind of food residues and crumbs, whether it be sticky sugar, caramel, greasy sauce, and it will be clean as new to be used again and again. Another advantage of using this silicone mat is that it can be put into the freezer, for example, for freezing your dumplings for later use, or for making frozen desserts.

​Pros

  • check
    The set consists of three identical mats for it is very useful for anyone who bakes several batches in one baking session
  • check
    The mat is safe to be used in the freezer as well as in the oven up to 480 degrees F
  • check
    The mat will securely sit on the countertop and give you a stable surface where you can shape and roll your dough
  • check
    It does not alter the flavor of the food and is resistant to staining
  • check
    Due to its non-stick property, it is very easy to clean

​Cons

  • check
    All three mats of the set are of the same size and design

Before buying silicone baking mats there are several factors that are very important to be considered so that you do not end up buying something that you do not need and are able to fix your mind only on the ones that are worth your time.

Things to consider before you buy a silicone baking mat 

What are the alternatives and why silicone baking mat could be your best choice

It is a hard decision to make for any baker or a chef to decide whether to go for a cooking spray, parchment papers or silicone baking mats. Although parchment papers are good to have in your kitchen drawer, in case you need to make something extra crispy, they are very wasteful since you can use a sheet of parchment paper only once. Also, they can stick to the baked items and it can be a real struggle to peel off a piece of parchment paper that gets stuck on the back of your cookie. Not only that they have very limited use compared to baking mats.

On the other hand, cooking spray is not really good for your health, although it can be a quick and easy option. Cooking spray can make your dish greasy and high in calorie content, and also affect the flavor of what you are baking. Compared to the other two, silicone baking mats are healthy, does not affect your food, and the best part is that they can be easily cleaned and used again and again. They also have the additional advantage of being able to stay in the freezer and go directly into the oven.

Fitting the mat onto your baking sheet or pan

One thing that silicone baking mat that is a little troublesome is the shape and size. Since most of them contain fiberglass in their construction, it is best not to cut them, since the fiberglass can come out and affect the safety of your food. But the good news is that you can choose different sizes of mats, for example, half-sheet and quarter-sheet, which would fit onto any standard baking trays. There are even sets of silicone baking mats that include two different sizes so you can have more flexibility with the size.

Color options 

For bakers who bake a wide variety of food, it is good to have dedicated mats for specific purposes. For example, there are sets of mats with different colored borders. So you can specify the red bordered mat for baking savory meat dishes and use the green bordered one for baking sweet desserts. Other than that, the middle of the mat can have white or pale brown semi-transparent surfaces, and you can choose which one suits your style depending on your preference.

Plain or with markings 

If you are a perfectionist, then you would want each of your cookies to have the same size and shape. And for that, markings or guides on the mat itself can be very useful since you do not have to depend on guesswork.

Conclusion 

A silicone baking mat is a lasting solution to many baking problems and would be one of your favorite baking accessories once you start using it. Now that you are fully aware of what to avoid and which ones to go for, you are ready to turn on your oven and start baking your favorite treats!
The 10 Best Silicone Baking Mats in 2018
5 (100%) 5 votes

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.